The DealMachine Real Estate Investing Podcast · David Lecko, Ryan Haywood

500: 15 High-Margin Deals Per Year in NYC—Here's How

February 20, 2026·29 min·2 clips
Rob Scamitti achieved an 8.68 return on ad spend from driving for dollars in NYC.
Rob Scamitti runs Cash4Keys.com and works the New York City market with just one other team member. He focuses on Queens, Long Island, and nearby areas. The episode starts from a simple point: flashy lead generation is not the only way to compete. Rob argues that in a market as competitive as New York City, going back to the basics can still cut through the noise. He uses driving for dollars as the channel he is watching most closely. That tracking is about more than vanity. It is meant to show how much gets spent and how much comes back, so he can see which marketing channel is efficient and what needs work. One example shows roughly $410,000 spent and just under $3 million generated on the driving-for-dollars list. The discussion makes clear that this figure is net revenue, not profit after every cost. That distinction keeps the numbers grounded. The hosts also ask whether the deals were wholesales or rehabs. Most of them were rehabs, with only three wholesale deals out of 26. A data issue comes up around one property record, and Rob says the list needs cleaning up. That moment fits the larger tone of the episode: real deal tracking is messy, and the value is in how the operator handles it. The episode also touches the difference between basic outbound work and PPC. Rob says PPC leads are much more competitive and require a stronger closing game. The practical takeaway is not that one channel is magic. It is that consistency, list quality, and better mailers still matter. The conversation keeps returning to what helps him stay steady in a hard market. It is a show about tactics, but it is really about discipline.

As heard by us

Basic lead gen, hard market numbers, and a reminder that consistency still wins.

Rob Scamitti makes a clear case for basic prospecting in a market that rewards simple habits and steady follow through. The episode stays close to the numbers: New York City, one other team member, driving for dollars, better mailers, and return math that shows where the edge…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a real-world look at how a tiny team cuts through one of the toughest markets in the country?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on