Austin Undercover: The Parking Lot Rendezvous

June 9, 2025·1 hr 10 min·5 clips

Austin describes filming a couple having sex in a Porsche Cayenne under a streetlight during a surveillance case.

Host Mackenzie, herself a PI, and co-host Hannah introduce Austin -- who operates as 'Austin the PI' on Instagram -- as the first guest PI in the show's history. Austin has nine years of experience working first with his father's FBI-affiliated firm before starting his own, with a focus split roughly 50/50 between criminal defense work and domestic/insurance surveillance cases. The conversation covers how PIs actually operate: Austin explains that the job involves far more digging through public records, court documents, and online sources than any kind of glamorous surveillance theater. He introduces PimEyes, a consumer-level facial recognition tool that can surface alternate online profiles, and CyberBackgroundChecks.com as free resources for everyday people vetting dating partners. Both PIs agree on a key misconception: most people believe they would notice if they were being followed, but surveillance professionals routinely monitor even highly trained military personnel without detection. Austin describes how he approaches criminal defense investigations -- reviewing discovery documents, identifying gaps in police work, and presenting attorneys with facts regardless of guilt or innocence, noting that the state often funds a PI for eligible defendants. The main story involves Jim, a 37-year-old Tallahassee man separated from his wife Melissa, who owned a nail salon. Jim hired the firm to surveil Melissa during a weekend girls trip to Panama City Beach. Austin describes the logistics of tracking her from the nail salon on a Friday evening, booking a hotel nearby, and following the group as they settled in for the weekend. The surveillance takes an unexpected turn in a parking lot involving a dog, which provides the episode's memorable comedic moment. Throughout, the hosts emphasize that PI work requires relentlessness and competitive drive rather than spy gadgetry, and that online tools now make basic background checks accessible to anyone.

As heard by us

A relationship-suspicion story that stays conversational while the PI details remain clear.

The Dating Detectives keeps the relationship-suspicion premise easy to track, and the PI work stays legible as it follows Jim and Melissa in Tallahassee, Florida, with two kids, a nail salon, and a planned girls' trip to Panama City Beach.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For a PI story that starts with a girls' trip and tightens into a surveillance run.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Dating Detectives