A Life Built on a Lie: Part 1

June 16, 2025·1 hr·5 clips

Andrea's husband admits his $10 million investment company was a sham, shattering their life.

Andrea Merriman grew up in Colorado as the oldest of five adopted children in an LDS family, where her orthodontist father hoped she'd become a concert pianist or take over his practice. After three years at Brigham Young University majoring in English pre-law, she met her future husband when he came to pay rent at the apartment complex where she worked. She initially wasn't interested in the short, non-athletic man with thinning hair and glasses who didn't fit her usual preference for tall athletes, but he had charisma and was universally well-liked in their community. He began love-bombing her with expensive symphony dates, fine dining, live music, flowers, and jewelry, including buying her a pearl necklace after seeing her borrow one from a roommate. Two to three years before meeting him, Andrea's father had died unexpectedly in a plane crash, leaving her vulnerable and seeking family connection. The relationship moved quickly from January to engagement in May 1989, when he proposed on a beach in Mendocino with a large ring despite never discussing marriage. Andrea felt stressed, worried she was too young, and told him she needed to think about it, but he put the ring on her hand anyway, interpreting her hesitation as "yes, pending verification." She was so anxious after the proposal that she couldn't eat dinner while he celebrated "the best meal of his life." When Andrea told her roommates about the engagement, they were shocked and asked "to who?"—her fiancé was their fifth guess out of five men she'd been dating. Her future mother-in-law chose the wedding date (August 5th, just two months away) based on her own schedule, and Andrea didn't meet his family until the day before the wedding. Immediately after marriage, Andrea discovered her husband had lied about having $17,500 in the bank for her tuition—the money was actually stereo equipment he claimed was equivalent to cash and that he was "interpreting" things for her. She also learned he hated beaches and dancing despite proposing on a beach and taking her dancing, and he stopped attending church and paying tithing as soon as they married. Andrea struggled in the first years of marriage, taking 20 credit hours while working 30 hours per week as he stayed home unemployed and criticized her for not doing laundry and cooking. She wrote in her journal about opening a separate savings account to pay tithing herself and told herself "I can always walk away from this until I have kids" for the first four to five years. However, her husband became successful as a stockbroker in Denver, making $50,000 in his first four months and $200,000 annually, which led him to abandon plans for an MBA at Dartmouth. After three years, he started his own investment company managing money for wealthy clients, and over the next 14-15 years, their net worth grew to $10 million. The conversation is structured as an interview where Andrea reflects candidly on her choices, acknowledging she was love-bombed though she didn't know the term at the time. The hosts validate her experiences and draw parallels to modern relationship dynamics, creating a supportive atmosphere. Andrea is forthcoming about red flags she missed and decisions she regrets, while also describing the prosperity and family life (four children) that made her eventually believe she'd made the right choice. The episode suits audiences interested in relationship red flags, financial abuse patterns, LDS dating culture of the 1980s-90s, and long-term deception narratives. This is explicitly Part 1 of a two-part story about financial abuse.

As heard by us

A relationship story that makes dating culture and social pressure feel like the point.

The episode takes a little while to find its shape, but that looseness gives the later material room to register. Once it settles, the most effective stretch is the one that treats the surprise as more than a joke: it follows the guest through dating several people, explains why…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a relationship story where the tension comes from social pressure, not a flashy twist.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Dating Detectives