RAGING AT "REVIEWERS"

·30 min·2 clips

“The audience is already in. The review is already in.”

Tuesday, September 30th, fall has shown up. The host starts loose: hellos, the season waking up, suitcases back in use, September trips to LA and Philadelphia, and a podcast lineup beginning to take form. Then Clay Hilly lands in the middle of the episode. The host treats him as the Heldentenor of the moment, newly connected to the Tucker Foundation and carrying Wagner roles that almost nobody can survive for long. The praise has a job to do. It tees up his anger at reviewers, especially when criticism slips from the singing into the body standing onstage. He names the double standard. A review would get torched for mocking someone for being fat, he says, but somehow a line about a singer's muscular arms gets waved through as normal. That is when the rant really starts breathing fire. He says he had to stop reading reviews himself, and then understood why soprano and tenor friends had already walked away from them. Fame, as he tells it, changes the rules. Once a singer becomes a name, sings big things, and takes big swings, people outside the room start treating them less like a person and more like public property. Clay is his example. The host insists Hilly is booked years out and gets top billing because that voice type is rare and the music is brutal. Wagner fans get the plain version: these parts were written for voices that barely exist, and the people who try them are taking real career risk. For the host, the audience matters. If the room went wild for Hilly, that applause cannot just be brushed aside by a critic who acts as if everyone else missed the obvious. A reviewer can dislike the performance. Fine. But they should own that they are disagreeing with the people in the hall. The point is respect, with teeth: respect for craft, bodies, risk, and listeners. Then he swings back to his calendar: the Met, a spring Don Carlo in Dallas with a major cast, and his first solo aria recording with orchestra and choir.

As heard by us

A blunt defense of a Wagner tenor, with a sharp case for trusting the crowd.

The episode starts with a fall-season check-in, then moves into a blunt defense of Clay Hilly, a Wagner tenor, and a sharp pushback against review culture.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a ferocious takedown of bad reviewing from inside the opera world?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The CVH Podcast