Jury trials to be scrapped: the verdict

·37 min·2 clips

Tara says jury service spent less than 50 percent of the day in court, with 10:30 starts and 4 p.m. finishes.

The episode opens with the jury as one of the great pillars of British justice, a constitutional and democratic safeguard. The hosts lay out the government's proposal to remove jury trials for most crimes and treat it as a test of whether ordinary people still decide guilt or whether more power shifts to the authorities. That tension shapes the whole discussion. Supporters call it a necessary fix for a system on the brink. Critics call it the biggest attack on the justice system this country has ever seen, and the episode uses that language to show how serious the stakes feel to people who see jury trial as part of the relationship between citizen and state. The backlog lands hard. The hosts cite a rape victim who, they say, may not reach trial until 2029, and they use that example to show how delay can feel like justice denied. They argue that if victims stop cooperating, witnesses stop giving statements, and people stop believing they will ever see justice, faith in the whole process begins to erode. The pressure does not stop there. Police numbers, lawyers, prison places, probation officers, and judges all come up as signs of a criminal justice system under strain, which is why the conversation keeps circling back to collapse rather than tidy reform. The tone stays blunt. By the end, the jury question has become a wider fight about fairness, transparency, trust, and how much power the state should hold over the public.

As heard by us

A blunt case for jury trials as the justice system strains and trust thins.

The Crime Agents makes a forceful case against the government plan to remove jury trials from most crimes, centering the question of who should judge guilt and what fairness looks like when that power shifts away from ordinary people and toward the state.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you like your justice fights with the gloves off, this one goes straight at jury trials.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Crime Agents