The Cordial Catholic · Keith Little

341: From Adventures in Odyssey to the Catholic Church (w/ Paul McCusker)

April 1, 2026·1 hr 36 min·8 clips
The Episcopal Church's split over sexuality forced McCusker to ask: who has the authority to interpret Scripture?
1. The Cordial Catholic episode 341 features Paul McCusker, writer of Adventures in Odyssey, discussing his conversion from evangelical Protestantism to Catholicism with host Keith Little. 2. Paul McCusker is a Peabody award-winning writer and director with over 50 books and productions, best known for Adventures in Odyssey and Focus on the Family Radio Theater, and currently serving as senior director of creative content for the Augustan Institute. 3. The episode's central question is how someone who was a cornerstone of evangelical audio drama culture came to convert to Catholicism. 4. Paul grew up in Bowie, Maryland, at Grace Baptist Church, with a culturally lapsed Catholic father and a staunchly anti-Catholic Methodist mother from Uniontown, Pennsylvania. 5. He describes Uniontown as a place where the various Methodist denominations 'only united in order to bash the Catholics,' establishing how foreign Catholicism was to his upbringing. 6. Paul's creative career began in evangelical church drama, writing sketches for a church variety show modeled on Saturday Night Live, then getting published because 'nobody was writing drama for churches.' 7. His career pivot came in 1985 when his father died and his Maryland employer was bought out, prompting him to relocate to Thousand Oaks, California, to work with Chuck Bolte of the Jeremiah People touring drama group. 8. In 1986 Chuck Bolte connected Paul with Focus on the Family, where he wrote for a pre-Odyssey series called Family Portraits; he joined Adventures in Odyssey staff in January 1988. 9. After marrying Elizabeth and moving to Mission Viejo, Paul grew disillusioned with seeker-sensitive non-denominational churches in Southern California, characterizing them as 'spiritual seven-elevens'—consumer-based and without clear conviction. 10. He and his wife drove past a Catholic church in Mission Viejo and Paul sensed 'something going on in there that may have been going on for 2,000 years,' but a visit revealed acoustic guitars and tambourines and they left without attending the mass. 11. When Focus on the Family relocated to Colorado Springs in 1990, Paul moved instead to England, where his wife Elizabeth is from, and began searching for a church. 12. After months of not connecting to any church, Paul and Elizabeth stopped at Christ Church of Virginia Water, a high Anglican parish described as 'borderline Anglo-Catholic,' and Paul felt immediately at home with the liturgy. 13. He describes the experience as connecting to a 'transcendent thing' the liturgy provided—bypassing intellectual resistance and resonating at a heart level he had not found in contemporary Protestant worship. 14. Paul also visited a 900-year-old church near Winchester called Nether Wallop and noted the continuity of a liturgy he was practicing that traced back to worship conducted in that building over 1,000 years ago. 15. He was received into the Anglican church and then into an Anglo-Catholic Episcopal congregation in Colorado Springs after Focus on the Family moved there. 16. Paul identifies Willow Creek's own retrospective study of its 30-year seeker movement—which concluded the effort was 'a mile wide and an inch deep'—as institutional confirmation that drawing people in without deepening discipleship failed. 17. He argues the church turned worship services into evangelistic tools starting perhaps with D.L. Moody in the late 1800s, and that the seeker movement represented a 'panic' response to cultural drift rather than a principled approach. 18. The episode is a long-form conversion interview structured as an oral history, with Keith prompting Paul at key moments and connecting Paul's journey to contemporary trends in Catholic conversion. 19. Evangelical Christians familiar with Adventures in Odyssey or Focus on the Family Radio Theater, or anyone curious about conversion from evangelical culture, would find this episode resonant. 20. Listeners seeking doctrinal instruction rather than personal narrative would likely find this episode less useful.

As heard by us

A layered conversion conversation that uses Anglicanism and church history to frame the road into Catholicism.

Keith Little's conversation with Paul McCusker charts a conversion path from Adventures in Odyssey toward Catholicism, with Scripture, tradition, and church history carrying most of the weight.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want an evangelical-convert-to-Catholic story that starts with Bible-or-tradition and keeps unfolding?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on