The Cordial Catholic · Keith Little

316: An Evangelical Guide to the Anointing of the Sick (w/ Dr. Michael Barber)

October 1, 2025·1 hr 16 min·6 clips
Dr. Barber argues that anointing the sick offers not just physical healing but conformity to Christ through suffering.
1. The Cordial Catholic episode 316 features Dr. Michael Barber, professor at the Augustan Institute, discussing his book The Bible and the Anointing of the Sick, published by Baker Academic. 2. Dr. Barber holds a position in Sacred Scripture and Theology at the Augustan Institute and has authored multiple works including Paul, A New Covenant Jew and The Historical Jesus and the Temple from Cambridge University Press. 3. The episode's central question is why the Catholic sacrament of anointing the sick uses oil, what the sacrament actually does, and how its roots run from the Old Testament through the New Testament and early church. 4. Dr. Barber defines the seven sacraments using the Catechism definition: 'powers that come forth from the body of Christ,' meaning Jesus' healing ministry continues through the Church. 5. He illustrates this continuity by showing how Luke's Acts deliberately mirrors Jesus' miracles with apostolic miracles—Jesus healing a lame man, then Peter healing a lame man—to demonstrate that what Jesus did in his public ministry continues in the Church. 6. The New Testament grounding comes from two passages: Mark 6, where Jesus sends the twelve apostles to anoint the sick with oil, and James 5, where elders are instructed to anoint those who are gravely ill. 7. Dr. Barber argues these passages prove anointing of the sick is apostolic in origin and not, as evangelicals might assume, a medieval invention or superstition. 8. The episode traces why oil in particular is used, noting its association in the ancient world with life, vitality, and healing—Psalm 104 on how oil causes the face to shine, Psalm 45's 'oil of gladness,' and the Good Samaritan pouring oil into wounds. 9. Dr. Barber explains that 'Christ' is not Jesus' last name but the Greek 'Christos,' meaning 'anointed one,' and that in ancient Israel, kings, priests, and prophets were all anointed ones. 10. Jesus as the anointed one par excellence unifies the sacrament's theology: to be anointed when sick is to be conformed to Christ as anointed king, priest, and prophet. 11. He addresses the apparent problem that anointed people often don't experience physical healing, explaining early Christians recognized two distinct effects: physical healing when God wills it, and spiritual healing (forgiveness of sins). 12. James 5 contains both dimensions, with the Greek word 'save' carrying both a health meaning and a spiritual salvation meaning, and the verse also promising forgiveness if the person has committed sins. 13. The biblical scholar P. Kyle McCarter, writing about royal anointing in the Old Testament, concluded that anointing was 'essentially a sacramental act'—language Dr. Barber uses to show a non-Catholic scholar recognizing the sacramental structure of Old Testament rites. 14. When Saul and David were anointed king by Samuel in the Old Testament, the Holy Spirit came upon them—demonstrating that the rite did something spiritually, not just symbolically. 15. Dr. Barber argues sacraments 'affect what they symbolize'—baptism in water is not merely a symbol but actually cleanses from sin in Christ, and anointing with oil is not merely a symbol but actually conforms the person to Christ. 16. The ultimate frame he offers is that the healing most desired is not indefinite biological life but 'to be conformed to Christ'—to be raised as Christ was raised on the last day. 17. Keith draws parallels between the Catholic sacrament and the charismatic evangelical practice of anointing with oil during altar calls, suggesting both spring from the same instinct derived from James 5. 18. The episode is structured as a didactic interview in which Keith consistently frames questions from an evangelical perspective and Dr. Barber answers with biblical scholarship and early church evidence. 19. Catholics seeking a scripturally grounded explanation of anointing of the sick, or evangelicals curious how this 'strange' Catholic practice is rooted in the New Testament, would benefit most. 20. Listeners wanting an experiential or devotional approach rather than a biblical theology lecture would find this episode too academic.

As heard by us

A clear, patient Catholic explanation of Anointing of the Sick.

The Cordial Catholic gives Anointing of the Sick a calm, careful treatment, moving from James's call to summon the elders to the harder question of what Catholics expect when healing does not come right away. Dr.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a careful Catholic explanation of the Anointing of the Sick that does not dodge the hard questions?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on