The Cold-Case Christianity Podcast · J. Warner Wallace

Are Christians Too Biased to be Trusted?

·1 hr 8 min·5 clips
Why Mormonism's recent claims face a higher evidential burden than ancient Christian artifacts.
The episode begins with a formal, slightly theatrical introduction and then settles into a warm welcome for first-time listeners. The host explains that the show is meant to answer questions and talk through current issues in more detail, and he notes that the first week of the month often brings new listeners through the email list. The tone stays conversational, but the structure is built for argument. The discussion quickly shifts to the relationship between truth and human beings. He asks what it would mean if people had to exist and agree before there could be any law of logic. He uses the law of identity and the law of non-contradiction as basic examples. The point is that these laws cannot begin with human beings. He argues that a thing cannot be both itself and not itself at the same time, even before people were around to notice it. From there, he pushes back on the idea that logic evolves along with humanity. He allows, as a concession, that an atheist might say humans evolved enough to recognize already existing laws. But he treats the claim that we create those laws as untenable. The reasoning comes across like a live conversation, with pauses, restarts, and clarifications. The host keeps circling back to the same claim from slightly different angles. That repetition is part of the method. It makes the argument feel like someone thinking aloud rather than reading a polished essay. The episode does not rush to a tidy flourish. It prefers to stack points until the conclusion feels unavoidable. Near the end, the show returns to practical listener logistics. The host invites people to join the guest map and the email list. The closing encouragement asks listeners to live in a way that makes others ask questions and to be ready to give an answer for the faith and hope they have in Jesus Christ. The final effect is earnest, grounded, and plainly argumentative.

As heard by us

A steady apologetics argument for logic as something people recognize, not invent.

The episode begins with a familiar apologetics question and settles into a measured defense of logic as something discovered rather than invented.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want a calm defense of truth that does not flinch.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on