The Chochmat Nashim Podcast: Women Talk Judaism · Jewish Coffee House

The Slippery Slope of Erasing Women: What Happened at Torah Tidbits (Season 8 Episode 1)

·32 min·3 clips
An Orthodox Union executive admitted he banned women from an ad page because one man found their pictures distracting during prayer.
Season eight opens with Anne Gordon and Shoshana Keats-Jeskel returning to a fight that has been building for years. The topic is the erasure of women in Orthodox media and communal life. They frame the conversation around a recent Times of Israel blog post by Shoshana, connected to the Orthodox Union. The hosts are careful to say they have real respect for the OU’s broader work. That respect does not reduce their concern. Their point is that a practice can begin as a small exception and still signal a larger shift in boundaries. They say this work was long in the making and involved meticulous research. The conversation keeps returning to what happens when women’s pictures are removed or excluded, and why that matters. Anne and Shoshana treat the issue as communal, not just symbolic. They describe a pattern that begins in the most insular Haredi and Hasidic spaces. From there, it can become normal in more mainstream Haredi communities. The fear is that it keeps moving outward into modern Orthodox and religious Zionist circles. They use the image of a human chain trying to protect a border that does not have enough guards. That makes the problem feel active and immediate rather than abstract. The hosts also push back on the assumption that more strictness is automatically better. Modesty is the example that shows how hard the line can be to draw. If the line is too loose, it becomes permissive; if it is drawn too tightly, women disappear. The episode ends with a call to make sure this does not keep encroaching into their own communities. It is an argument for naming the line while there is still time to hold it.

As heard by us

A blunt warning about how modesty talk can slide into women's erasure.

Season eight opens with a careful look at public women's images in Orthodox life, and the hosts keep the focus on erasure rather than a vague culture-war dispute.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want to hear how a tiny boundary can turn into a communal fault line.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on