The Charity Charge Show - Nonprofit Podcast · Charity Charge

Pamela Davis on Nonprofits Insurance, Risk, and Staying Mission Driven for 35 Years

·44 min·2 clips

Davis says, “insurance is like electricity” because you can’t have it only some years.

1. The Charity Charge Show episode centers on Pamela Davis and the Nonprofit Insurance Alliance’s work insuring nonprofits across California and 32 other states. 2. Stephen Garton interviews Pamela Davis, founder and CEO of the Nonprofit Insurance Alliance, because her organization insures about 26,000 to 27,000 nonprofits. 3. The episode asks why nonprofits need their own insurer and how a nonprofit-owned insurance model stays mission driven for 35 years. 4. Davis says her idea started with a UC Berkeley public policy thesis written as a returning student in her thirties. 5. She says the thesis was funded by the California Community Foundation and the Conrad Hilton Foundation, then published in 5,000 copies. 6. Davis says the California Association of Nonprofits offered to be the fiscal agent when she raised money to create the first California insurer. 7. She says the California organization insured about 12,000 nonprofits, while the other main insurer covers about 13,000 to 14,000 organizations in 32 other states. 8. Davis says the two organizations together now have about a billion dollars in assets and are about 35 years old. 9. She explains that the nonprofit sector still needs practical coverage such as general liability for fundraisers and board and executive coverage for all-volunteer groups. 10. Davis says social service professional coverage, improper sexual conduct and physical abuse coverage, and non-owned or hired auto coverage become important as organizations work with vulnerable populations or use vehicles. 11. She says a small nonprofit can still need insurance because a slip-and-fall at a fundraiser or a rented venue can create immediate liability. 12. Davis says many organizations do not understand their legal obligations, do not train staff enough, or do not keep the right documentation. 13. She says nonprofit leaders often face a constant choice between spending money on governance or spending it directly on community service. 14. Davis says the organization is one of one or two insurers that still welcomes small nonprofits, including some with $25,000 to $50,000 budgets. 15. She says special-event policies can be less useful than an annual policy because event planning and outreach happen before and after a single event. 16. Davis says the organization recently saw 94 inquiries in five days through its website, which she treats as evidence of real demand. 17. She describes the interview style as conversational and detailed, with Stephen Garton pressing for practical advice, history, and process. 18. Davis speaks in a mix of policy history, operational detail, and direct guidance, including her description of insurance as "like electricity." 19. People running small nonprofits, board members, and nonprofit brokers would get the most from this episode. 20. Listeners wanting celebrity interviews or light entertainment probably would skip it.

As heard by us

A grounded look at nonprofit owned insurance and the policy work behind it.

Pamela Davis and Stephen Garton keep the focus on a simple idea: nonprofit insurance works differently when it is owned and run for the sector itself.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Hear how nonprofit insurance, advocacy, and mission-first scale fit together.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Charity Charge Show - Nonprofit Podcast