The British History Podcast · Jamie Jeffers

That's Me In The Corner

·37 min·2 clips

Gerard kicked over the lower chair after seeing Anselm given the high seat.

1. The British History Podcast episode “That’s Me In The Corner” follows Anselm’s council at Westminster Abbey and the power struggle around Henry I. 2. Anselm of Canterbury, Archbishop Gerard of York, King Henry, and Pope Pascal II matter because they shape the church-state conflict. 3. The episode asks whether Anselm can finally force reform while Henry keeps control of appointments and consecrations. 4. Anselm has been trying for years to hold a major reform council, and Henry allows it where Rufus refused. 5. The council is described as a hurried two-day event at Westminster Abbey with magnates, officials, and the king present part-time. 6. Gerard of York sees a high seat prepared for Anselm and a lower seat for himself, then kicks over the chair in protest. 7. Hugh the Chanter and Edmer give different versions of who was meant to outrank whom at the council. 8. The council targets pointy shoes, married clergy, sodomy, garish clothing, drunkenness, boozy ecclesiastical parties, and lax monastic discipline. 9. The episode says Lanfranc had already banned pointy shoes in 1076 and that Anselm repeats the ban for clergy. 10. Simony is treated differently because the episode says there are records of enforcement and charter evidence for buying and selling church offices. 11. The narration argues that simony is easier to investigate than sexual misconduct because it leaves documents behind. 12. The episode says the royal and church incentives align against simony because seized lands and titles can be redistributed. 13. Henry uses the council to remove abbots and replace them with men more useful to his rule, including a monk from Mont-Saint-Michel. 14. Richard de Clair of Ely is described as a powerful noble tied to the de Clairs and the Giffords, which makes him a target when he fails to answer Henry quickly enough. 15. Robert of Bury St. Edmunds is removed because the monks loathe him and his political usefulness has faded. 16. Henry then presses Anselm on investiture, and Anselm refuses to consecrate William Gifford, Roger of Salisbury, and Reinhelm of Hereford. 17. William of Winchester is treated differently because Anselm himself had invested him, but Henry insists on all or nothing. 18. The episode’s tone is sardonic and fast-moving, with modern comparisons to Taskmaster, mediation, and civil-service bureaucracy. 19. Listeners interested in Norman church politics and royal power struggles. 20. Listeners wanting a purely devotional or church-history-only account.

As heard by us

Anselm's Westminster council turns reform into a fight over power, simony, and church offices.

The episode uses Westminster Abbey's first primatial council since William the Conqueror to frame a reform push that is also a struggle over power and staffing.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get Anselm, Henry, and a rushed reform council at Westminster Abbey that smells like office politics.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The British History Podcast