The Brainy Business | Understanding the Psychology of Why People Buy | Behavioral Economics · Melina Palmer

Buycotting for Change

August 7, 2025·40 min·4 clips
How did 2% of consumers force the tuna industry to stop killing millions of dolphins?
Melina opens the episode with a conversation about behavioral economics and the ways people can use consumer pressure to create change. Dr. Diane Osgood joins to walk through the difference between boycotts and other kinds of consumer action. The discussion stays focused on the choices people make: speaking publicly, writing directly to a company, or changing their own habits. Osgood argues that change works better when it has more than one path. She says it takes an ecosystem to create change. She also points out that what feels natural for one person may not fit another person's skill set or temperament. If someone is good at social media and giving their opinion, that can be one kind of contribution. If someone would rather stay private, a letter to a company can still matter. The episode keeps coming back to the idea that people should choose the role that makes them feel both effective and proud. Osgood then shares a personal campaign that she says is the first time she's talked about publicly. Her concern is mica sourcing in cosmetics. She explains that mica is what makes products sparkly, including lipstick, blush, nail polish, and plenty of other items. She notes that most of it comes from India, especially two states with a very high prevalence of child labor. She says that if a product includes mica and gives no clear disclaimer about its source, it is probably tied to child labor concerns. Her response has been to write to cosmetic companies and ask where their mica comes from. She also asks whether they are part of any effort to improve conditions for kids, replace mica, or use a better source. She says it is surprising how many companies never reply. Even so, she believes enough letters will be heard over time. The conversation treats that kind of private action as just as real as a louder public campaign. It also leaves room for people who prefer a more visible, collective push. The larger point is that values-based buying is not one single move. It is a mix of personal comfort, practical action, and the kind of pressure that can build when enough people take part.

As heard by us

A clear look at how buying choices can become one way to push for change.

This conversation stays practical about consumer power and keeps circling back to a plain question: what role can a person actually play? Dr. Diane Osgood gives the discussion shape by separating the public gesture from quieter moves like writing to companies, and by showing how…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to make your shopping a practical lever for change, without turning it into a crusade.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on