The Big Picture · The Big Picture

The End of the End of History? Grand Strategy with Emma Sky

October 19, 2022·58 min·4 clips
Emma Sky argues 9/11 itself didn't end the liberal world order — America's response did.
The conversation begins with the 20-year reunion of the World Fellows Program. Emma Skye describes the gathering as deeply memorable. She talks about how many alumni came from across the world, and she also notes the absence of several fellows who are prisoners of conscience. That gives the discussion an emotional and political weight before it opens up. The host then steers the exchange toward the 1990s and the rise of neoconservative thinking in the United States. Skye looks at the confidence that surrounded that period. She describes a worldview that treated American power and liberal democracy as something to be exported. She links that instinct to humanitarian intervention and to the belief that ungoverned spaces could not simply be left alone. The conversation then turns to Tony Blair and his role in that period. Skye suggests that Blair's interventionist posture came from the same confidence and had consequences that lasted. The war becomes the central case study. She notes the difference between American and British public opinion. She describes the scale of anti-war protest in the UK. She also says the war destroyed Blair's reputation completely. From there the discussion widens into the moral damage the war did to the United States itself. Skye and the host talk through Abu Ghraib as a stark rupture. They touch on extraordinary rendition. They discuss detention without due process. They mention targeted killings as part of the changed language of security. The tone stays serious and reflective throughout. The host listens, sums up, and keeps the analysis moving without hurrying it. Skye keeps returning to the idea that fear and revenge can make a democracy violate its own standards. The closing movement shifts away from diagnosis and toward action. Skye argues that people should not just wait for governments to fix everything. She calls for networks, new institutions, and new ways of operating. The ending is deliberately constructive. It leaves the listener with the sense that history is not closed and that agency still matters.

As heard by us

A sober foreign-policy conversation that turns hindsight into a case for agency.

This conversation treats foreign policy as a lived argument, beginning with the World Fellows reunion and then following Emma Sky through the 1990s and the post-9/11 years, when Western confidence hardened into intervention, overreach, and moral strain.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a serious foreign-policy conversation that actually builds toward something.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on