Elon Buys Twitter: What’s Next for the World’s Town Square?

November 15, 2022·55 min·4 clips

A fake Lockheed Martin account with a blue check tweeted about halting weapons sales, going viral.

The episode opens with hosts Belabes Benkreder and Raheel Khurshid framing the discussion as the inaugural Yale Public Sphere Salon, focused on Twitter's rapid deterioration under Elon Musk's ownership. Khurshid recaps the six-month acquisition saga: Musk proposed the deal, Twitter resisted, the board was forced to accept, Musk tried to walk away, a court battle forced his hand, and ownership transferred roughly two weeks before the recording. Khurshid, who spent nearly five years at Twitter, describes the first two weeks as a dumpster fire, citing the arrival of people unfamiliar with the platform's culture and product. The layoffs are described as affecting more than 50% of staff, with attrition expected to push that figure toward 75%, including heads of public policy, trust and safety, and key relationship managers. Reports emerged that some laid-off employees were being asked to return, illustrating how poorly the process was executed. A New York Times investigation based on 36 current and former staff interviews is cited as confirming the internal chaos. Khurshid argues that Musk is applying a hardware-company, black-and-white mindset to a platform that requires nuance, particularly in content moderation, which he says was imperfect but functional. The $8 Twitter Blue verification rollout is examined in detail: it removed the distinction between authentic notable accounts and anyone willing to pay, immediately enabling impersonation of Tesla, Lockheed Martin, George Bush, Tony Blair, Dave Chappelle, and Nintendo. The hosts highlight a fake Lockheed Martin tweet announcing a halt to weapons sales to Saudi Arabia, Israel, and the US as an example of the national security risks the chaos could produce. Benkreder and Khurshid explain why Twitter's influence is disproportionate to its 220-225 million user base: every world leader, major journalist, and significant institution is on the platform, and the morning news agenda is effectively set there before spreading to other media. They contrast Twitter with Facebook, arguing the comparison has always been misleading because Twitter functions as an open town square where anyone can join any conversation, unlike Facebook's more closed social graph. The hosts discuss how Musk's debt load — converting roughly $50 million in annual interest payments to $1-1.5 billion — is forcing a desperate search for quick monetization that is incompatible with the platform's nature. Khurshid outlines a more thoughtful version of Twitter Blue that could bundle access to paywalled publications like the New York Times, New Yorker, and Financial Times, arguing there is a legitimate subscription product to be built — just not the one that was rolled out. The political dimension is explored: Musk's alignment with Silicon Valley libertarians around Peter Thiel, his open call for Republican votes in the midterms, and the parallel to Thiel's funding of the lawsuit that destroyed Gawker are all discussed as evidence of a political project embedded in the acquisition. Khurshid pushes back on the narrative that Twitter was a left-wing platform, arguing it was broadly centrist and in some global contexts, such as India, actually accommodated government requests under national security frameworks. The hosts discuss Jack Dorsey's Blue Sky project as a potential Web3-based decentralized alternative, and assess Mastodon as currently unable to handle Twitter-scale traffic without significant capital investment. Khurshid reflects personally on the pain of watching the platform he worked on for years deteriorate, noting that friends he made through Twitter over 12 years represent real social capital that cannot easily be rebuilt elsewhere. He expresses hope that Musk will tire of the project, sell at a massive loss, and that a new owner will reconstitute Twitter as a non-profit public utility, citing Change.org and Signal as precedents for that kind of transition. The episode closes with both hosts agreeing that even a Musk course-correction cannot restore the communities — disability rights, LGBTQIA, academic, activist — whose supporting infrastructure has been dismantled, and that Twitter is entering a permanently altered era as a public sphere.

As heard by us

A careful look at Twitter's turmoil and the strain it puts on public trust.

This episode treats Elon Musk's purchase of Twitter as a stress test for the platform's claim to be a public square. The hosts move through the early turmoil and stay focused on the harder questions around verification, trust, publisher relationships, and what happens when the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a clear read on why Twitter’s verification shakeup matters beyond the headlines.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Big Picture