MLB Early Season Trends & Work Stoppage Fear w/ Sports Illustrated’s Ryan Phillips

April 8, 2026·26 min·2 clips

The Pirates lock up 19-year-old Connor Griffin with a nine-year, $140 million deal, the largest in team history.

1. The Baseball Insiders episode welcomes Sports Illustrated MLB writer Ryan Phillips alongside regular co-host Robert Murray to assess early-season trends approximately ten games into the 2026 MLB season. 2. Host Adam Weinrub leads the conversation; Robert Murray is a FanSided MLB insider; Ryan Phillips covers MLB for Sports Illustrated and recently wrote about the looming CBA work stoppage. 3. The episode's primary thread is whether early-season struggles and surprises are signal or noise, evaluated across the Cubs, Red Sox, Mets, Giants, Blue Jays, Tigers, Mariners, Dodgers, and Padres. 4. The Cubs lost starting pitcher Cate Horton for the season within the first ten games, compounding an earlier loss of Justin Steel, which Murray and Phillips say will push them toward in-house options like Ben Brown before exploring the trade market. 5. Lucas Giolito remains unsigned as of the recording and both analysts describe this as surprising; Murray says the Blue Jays are the most logical landing spot given their rotation injuries, including a Max Scherzer early exit. 6. Pittsburgh's Connor Griffin extension — nine years, $140 million, up to $150 million, the largest deal in Pirates history — was announced the same day, with Weinrub noting it represents a shift toward organizational commitment under owner Bob Nutting. 7. Ryan Phillips says Roman Anthony's throw against the Brewers is the kind of play 'I'll be on my deathbed and that'll be running through my head,' adding that third base coaches around the league are now waving runners aggressively. 8. Weinrub speculates the throw is so uncharacteristic of a scouted prospect that an undisclosed injury is the most plausible explanation, noting Anthony has delivered increasingly distressed post-game quotes despite being treated as a potential franchise cornerstone. 9. Phillips rates the Mets as capable of holding serve without Juan Soto while he recovers, citing Nolan McLain's developing arsenal as 'as good as any right-handed arsenal in baseball' and expressing confidence in Francisco Lindor and Pete Alonso. 10. On the Giants, Phillips calls Tony Vitello's first-year managerial experiment 'a very bad bold move by Buster Posey' and says the club lacks upside everywhere on the roster except Rafael Devers, who has not performed to the level expected of the trade acquisition. 11. Harrison Bader and Louisa Rise are described as 'fine major league players but not difference makers,' insufficient to close the gap between a .500 team and the Dodgers. 12. Murray says he is not panicking about the Blue Jays, Tigers, or Mariners despite all three sitting below .500, citing the Mariners' offseason acquisitions including Brendan Donovan and the imminent arrival of Colt Emerson. 13. On the Dodgers, Robert Murray praises the front office for acquiring James Tibbs from the Red Sox in the Dustin May trade and says Tibbs is performing well enough at Triple-A that a major league call-up this season is possible. 14. Freddie Pahes is praised as one of the least-paid yet most productive players on the Dodgers' roster, with Murray saying the NL All-Star lineup around him is a luxury. 15. The Padres segment focuses on whether Joe Musgrove will return, whether Randy Vasquez's emergence is real, and whether Michael Kane can replicate a pre-injury level of performance; Giolito is raised as a potential fit, with Murray noting Nick Pavetta's agent also represents Giolito and used a backloaded contract structure that could work again. 16. Phillips closes the episode with a detailed argument on the CBA work stoppage: he says the incoming prospect class is the most talented he has ever seen, making this a particularly costly moment for missed games, but that the RSN collapse has created a financial divide that must be addressed. 17. He predicts no salary cap but anticipates a harder luxury tax ceiling and a new salary floor as the core negotiation axes, calling both 'hard won' for both sides. 18. The episode is structured as a fast-paced three-way conversation with rapid topic transitions, overlapping commentary, and light banter between the hosts. 19. Best for engaged MLB fans who follow multiple teams, front-office moves, and labor issues, and want analytical commentary with insider sourcing. 20. Likely to frustrate casual fans or listeners focused on a single team, as the episode covers ten franchises in roughly 25 minutes with no sustained deep dives.

As heard by us

A sharp MLB conversation that turns early noise into roster questions.

Baseball Insiders stays close to the early season questions that actually matter. Adam Weinrub, Robert Murray, and Ryan Phillips move briskly through roster building, star expectations, and the line between a hot start and real signal.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a fast baseball check-in on how early-season pressure, roster depth, and trade-chip chatter are landing in the room.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Baseball Insiders