The Art of Manliness · The Art of Manliness

How the World Wars Shaped J.R.R. Tolkien and C.S. Lewis

November 18, 2025·42 min·3 clips

How did Tolkien convince C.S. Lewis that Christianity is the 'myth that became fact' during a walk at Oxford?

A children's tale is the starting point. The host asks whether Tolkien was writing mainly for children or reaching for something larger. The answer lands in the middle. Tolkien told stories to his children, but he took them seriously enough that adults could feel the weight too. Lewis worked in a similar lane. Both writers wanted children to meet darkness without being stranded there. The dragon matters because it gives evil a shape. The guest treats it as radical evil, not set dressing. The host follows that thread into Tolkien's faith in ordinary people facing what looks too large for them. Sam Gamgee is the hinge. The guest says Tolkien linked Sam to the English soldier he knew in the First World War, which makes the hobbits feel less cute and more stubbornly honorable. Their smallness becomes part of the point. The conversation stays practical and literary: children's fiction as a place to practice noticing tragedy, courage, and heroes. Then January 1938 darkens the room. Tolkien's address arrives with Europe under pressure from totalitarian states, Italian fascism, and German Nazism. This reading treats fantasy as preparation, not escape.

As heard by us

A brisk reading of children's fantasy that keeps evil, courage, and adult meaning in the same frame.

Tolkien and Lewis are framed as writers who aimed at children without closing the door on adults, and that is where the piece has its best footing.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

How war shaped Tolkien and Lewis.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from The Art of Manliness