The Adam Friedland Show

ANTHONY FANTANO | Radiohead, Abbey Road, Drake vs. Kendrick

·56 min·5 clips
Adam Friedland introduces music critic Anthony Fantano after revealing his own secret acoustic guitar YouTube channel with only four subscribers.
The host asks whether people who constantly interact with Fantano's opinions amount to a community. Fantano says several million people can still lack much cohesion. The host brings up a ranking where In Rainbows lands ahead of Kid A. Fantano stands by it. Then the host asks why the albums need to sit above or below each other at all. Fantano says criticism requires breaking some eggs. The host keeps pressing until the defense begins to sound like its own fresh argument. The host asks what would happen if a critic simply called albums good. Fantano replies that not everything is good. The distinction gets trickier when the albums in question are all treated as very good. The host keeps searching for the purpose behind the rankings. Fantano keeps defending the value of offering an opinion anyway. The conversation sits with the idea that criticism needs friction to hold attention. It also admits that the stakes of the argument do not really matter. That admission does not stop the host from coming back to the question. Later, the discussion shifts to a song with a Donald Trump reference. Fantano describes it as being about strange right-wing people he sees online. The host asks whether he will keep practicing new diss tracks on Trump. Fantano says he is more likely to keep practicing by writing and recording different kinds of songs. The show closes with a quick exchange of thanks and a goodbye.

As heard by us

A sharp, funny argument about album rankings and why criticism needs friction.

The episode is at its best when an argument over album rankings turns into a broader question about criticism itself. If Kid A and In Rainbows are both plainly strong records, why does anyone need to place one above the other?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to decide whether In Rainbows beats Kid A, then ask what any of that ranking is actually for.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on