Jacob Collier can make anyone sing

March 17, 2026·55 min·4 clips

Collier argues that human unpredictability is a superpower in the AI era — 'competence has never made me cry' — and that our biological limits, our need for love, our inefficiency, are precisely what make art matter.

1. Switched on Pop presents a live piano conversation with musician Jacob Collier and impromptu guest Sam Sanders, recorded at On Air Fest in Brooklyn. 2. Charlie Harding (songwriter, host) conducts the interview; Sam Sanders (co-host of Vibe Check, host of The Sam Sanders Show on KCRW) was pulled from the audience five minutes before the show; Jacob Collier is the subject, described as an expert in Western harmony, negative harmony, and microtonalism. 3. The episode's central question is how music is heard, made, and taught — and why most people underestimate their own musicianship. 4. Collier has just finished his Jesse quadrilogy — four albums involving over 50 collaborators from Herbie Hancock to Anushka Shankar — and his most recent project, The Light for Days, is a comparatively minimalist set of songs written on a five-string guitar. 5. Collier describes being in New York for a month, the longest he has been in one place since COVID, and names Sandbox Percussion — four classically trained percussionists — as a recent musical discovery that excited him. 6. Sam Sanders raises the question of whether streaming and algorithmic playlists have weakened people's relationship with music by bypassing the active process of choosing what to listen to. 7. Collier responds that listening and making music are 'more similar than people think' — both involve diagnosing your current state and asking 'what do I wish existed right now?' — and that the algorithm's harm is in removing that self-diagnostic step. 8. Collier describes organizing his own playlists by sensation rather than genre: 'upwards,' 'downwards,' emoji-based categories, and a public playlist called 'Jacob's Optimum Music Feast' with approximately 20,000 songs. 9. At the piano, Collier explains harmony by connecting it to intuitions everyone already has — high/low, bright/dark, rough/smooth — and demonstrates how chords can evoke feelings of density, spaciousness, or depth without any prior music theory knowledge. 10. He demonstrates harmonic tension by holding the bass note F constant while changing the chords above it, letting the audience hold the note and feel the tension accumulate and release in real time. 11. Collier's audience choir method involves opening every show with 'hey-oh,' diagnosing the room's harmonic capability from that single response, and building up to three-part chords — a process he has used in arenas, concert halls, and outdoor festival stages. 12. He states that 'permission is more important than skill' and frames his role as conductor, producer, and performer as making the people he works with feel powerful rather than intimidated: 'I'm only as powerful as I make you feel.' 13. Collier describes his own musical education as requiring 'a lot of space to wiggle around, clear limitations and boundaries, and then forgiveness of me going over every line possible,' and notes this works only for a particular type of brain. 14. He recommends that musicians who have lost their relationship with music go back to what they first loved: for him, Stevie Wonder, Bobby McFerrin, Freddie Mercury, and Johann Sebastian Bach are still the foundations. 15. Collier shares a melody lesson from guitarist Mike Walker: play a melody, then sing it, then close your eyes and imagine a girl singing you a melody — and sing back exactly what she sings. The imagined melody had 'so much rhyme and balance and order and poetry and symmetry' that the lesson ended there. 16. He describes a building-block improvisation exercise: start with one note, add another note, then another, like the children's game 'I went to the market and I bought a fish,' demonstrating it live at the piano. 17. The episode is a live public interview with a warm, playful dynamic — Harding and Sanders frequently redirect the conversation, and Collier performs demonstrations at the piano that the audience participates in, creating an unusually interactive episode for the format. 18. Collier's tone combines rigorous musical analysis with a philosophical sensibility — he traces harmony to 'high/low, bright/dark' intuitions, connects melody to the heart and gut rather than the brain, and frames creativity as 'playing' in the deepest sense. 19. Listeners who want to hear a working musician explain music theory in plain language while actually demonstrating it on piano will find this episode substantive and unusual. 20. Listeners who prefer structured topic-by-topic analysis rather than a free-flowing live conversation will find the episode's improvisational structure harder to follow.

As heard by us

A case for singing that treats the crowd like an instrument.

Jacob Collier comes across as a strong argument for singing as something shared, not reserved for people with formal training. The focus stays on his audience-choir practice, on the way he starts with simple call and response, and on how quickly a room can reveal what it is…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Hear Jacob Collier test a room, then turn it into a choir.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Switched on Pop