Surviving the Survivor: #BestGuests in True Crime · Surviving the Survivor

NEW FBI Statement: Glove with Male DNA Could Match The Suspect from Surveillance Video

·1 hr 38 min·5 clips

Cheryl McCollum says the blood pattern looks like an injury, a cough, and a transfer from another object.

1. Surviving the Survivor: #BestGuests in True Crime centers on the Nancy Guthrie investigation and new FBI-related DNA reporting. 2. Joel Waldman hosts the episode, with retired homicide detective Phil Ramos, CSI expert Cheryl McCollum, retired FBI special agent Phil Andrew, and retired NYPD detective David Sarnie as the main voices. 3. The episode asks whether the case looks like a burglary gone wrong, what the glove DNA means, and whether investigators really believe Nancy Guthrie is alive. 4. CBS 5 Phoenix says an inside source now supports the burglary-gone-wrong theory rather than an intended kidnapping. 5. The same CBS 5 report says DNA evidence from a Range Rover outside Culver's is being tested. 6. Waldman repeats the report that investigators' widespread belief is that Nancy Guthrie could be alive. 7. Ramos says most people he has spoken with already leaned toward a burglary or home-invasion scenario. 8. McCollum says the ransom letters were "bogus" from day one and that money never made sense. 9. McCollum describes the suspect's behavior on surveillance as odd and says the backpack could have been meant to carry stolen items. 10. Andrew says a burglar would usually leave with something, but the case raises the question of why the person also took Guthrie. 11. McCollum says the black glove found near the road matches the video better than the blue gloves investigators wore. 12. She notes the glove looked longer on the arm and that its location on the correct side of the road could fit a driver tossing it out. 13. Ramos says criminals leave mistakes behind, citing Kohberger's knife sheath and BTK's floppy disk as examples. 14. McCollum breaks down the blood on the stoop as four distinct patterns, including 90-degree drops, a spray, a transfer pattern, and a swipe. 15. She says the blood looks consistent with a nose or mouth injury and possibly coughing. 16. Sarnie says nighttime burglars are often the most dangerous and asks what was removed from the house that did not belong there. 17. The conversation stays fast, interrupting, and reactive, with Waldman repeatedly replaying the CBS 5 clip and pushing each guest for a live read. 18. The format mixes breaking-news playback, forensic analysis, and guest banter about books, politics, and prior cases. 19. True-crime listeners who follow forensic detail and live case analysis. 20. Listeners wanting a calm, linear, spoiler-free recap.

As heard by us

A brisk update that treats the DNA lead as serious without calling the case solved.

Week three of the search for Nancy Guthrie has a bit more lift to it, mostly because investigators have a plausible male DNA lead from a black glove found almost two miles from the scene.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the latest forensic lead without losing the bigger search picture.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Surviving the Survivor: #BestGuests in True Crime