Style Thief Fashion Podcast · Erin Stoll

Episode 25: The Secondhand Shop That's Reshaping How I Think About Fashion

·41 min·4 clips

Shopping at Clothes Mentor keeps dollars local, supports women-owned businesses, and offers pristine secondhand items—many still with tags.

Erin starts inside Clothes Mentor for her first remote recording, with Andrea McCarter beside her and the store doing half the scene-setting. The episode stays practical. It is about resale, styling, and why secondhand pieces are easier to trust once someone puts them into real outfits. Erin keeps coming back to the same everyday snag: a shirt, shoe, bag, or trend piece can look cute by itself and still leave you wondering, "but with what?" Her answer is to make it visual. She talks through pulling pieces from Clothes Mentor's website for her summer style guide and turning them into complete looks. Shoes become the starting point. Bags, tops, bottoms, and accessories become little proof points for stretching a wardrobe without rebuilding it. The style guide matters because Erin mixes secondhand finds with new pieces, so resale does not feel like a separate fashion lane. It feels like another place to find outfits you would actually wear. Andrea's store becomes the classroom, but in a relaxed way. Erin uses Clothes Mentor as a spot where styling questions, trend nerves, and a few overlooked pieces can meet. If an eyelet puff-sleeve shirt would normally get passed over, she wants to show the jeans-and-outfit version that makes it click. The best part is the rough, working-through feel: the late-night idea, the memos to Andrea, the whittling down, and the reminder not to overwhelm people. Listeners leave with permission to try resale, use a guide, look for combinations, and decide whether a piece belongs in their own wardrobe. Erin closes by pointing people toward the style guides, Clothes Mentor's website, and more conversations about secondhand, fall dressing, holiday styling, and denim.

As heard by us

A remote secondhand-shopping visit that makes styling feel concrete and usable.

Style Thief treats a remote stop at Clothes Mentor as more than a bargain hunt. Erin Stahl and Andrea McCarter work through pieces from the store and show how they can come together into complete outfits, so the focus lands on styling that people can actually use rather than on…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Build better outfits from secondhand pieces without guessing.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Style Thief Fashion Podcast