Street Smart Success

700: Scared Money Creates Opportunity in Multifamily Markets

·35 min·3 clips
Danny Catan reveals why doctors and syndicators lost millions playing with variable debt in multifamily.
The host opens by revisiting a conversation with Danny Catan from summer 2024. Catan, a founder of PIA Residential, describes the current multifamily market as weird and still taking shape. He says many real estate participants are licking their wounds after deals went bad, while being clear that he is talking about multifamily because that is the lane he knows. The host pushes him to separate today's conditions from those earlier market conditions. Catan's answer comes back to pricing, buyer behavior, and the difficulty of knowing whether the market has actually reached its bottom. The field has narrowed from about thirty buyers to ten. Catan adds that roughly half of those remaining are trying to buy properties at half the price with no money down, which makes buyer activity harder to read. He estimates that the properties he is looking at are about 30 percent cheaper than at the peak. He avoids giving a neat bottom call. For Catan, the bottom can be opportunistic: an investor is already there, buying, when somebody calls. The conversation then turns back to 2008, 2009, and 2010. Catan recalls offering a small Miami house for $60,000, proposing $30,000 in repairs, and charging $15,000 to assign the deal. He says buyers still rejected that setup because they feared another market decline, even with substantial cash in the bank. The example puts his argument in practical terms: attractive pricing can be right there while buyers wait for someone else to confirm it. He points to the three-year delay before Wall Street entered Invitation Homes, which he places in 2011. Warren Buffett's view appears in Catan's explanation of how that confirmation changed the market's response to a business he already thought made sense. The interview stays skeptical about crowd timing, especially after the host notes that buyers are still showing up. Catan's examples keep circling back to price, cash requirements, and the risk buyers are willing to stomach. Near the end, he talks about his years living in Colombia, backpacking through Africa and Asia, and climbing Kilimanjaro. He closes by saying the mountain was easier than running multifamily, then compares that with the tougher period when the single-family operation had bulletproof glass in its reception area.

As heard by us

A multifamily investor explains why cheaper prices do not automatically create confident buyers.

Street Smart Success catches Danny Catan, founder of PIA Residential, in a multifamily market that looks cheaper but still feels uneasy. He describes investors nursing losses, some properties sitting about 30 percent below the peak, and buyers trying to decide whether the…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You step into a multifamily market that feels weird: fewer buyers than the peak, some fishing for half-price deals with no money down, and assets being discussed around 30% cheaper than before.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on