Strangers in Space

Who Review 43: The War Between the Land and the Sea Week 2

·50 min·4 clips
JR, John, and Matt reveal their split verdict on the first two episodes of 'The War Between the Land and the Sea'.
JR opens the review by setting episodes three and four as the focus. John and Matt join him, and the panel quickly remembers how Matt liked the first two episodes most, JR liked them least, and John landed somewhere between them. The conversation moves straight into episode three. Matt had been waiting to see what would happen at the bottom of the ocean, though the others wonder whether "looking forward" is really the right phrase. The group agrees that the visit to the Sea Devils' undersea base does not fully pay off two episodes of build-up around a journey into the deep. They compare that undersea civilization with the Silurian story Hungry Earth. That comparison opens a broader argument about what kind of Sea Devil civilization the story could have shown. The panel also brings in The Shape of Water while discussing a character who, as they read her, is neither fish nor reptile. That uncertainty pushes them toward the idea that the story might have worked better if it had embraced fantasy more openly. The mermaid comparison arrives as a joke, but it also sharpens the criticism. Episode four was expected to put the characters on the run from the authorities. The panel notes that the supposed chase mostly amounts to the couple lying in bed after sex while lights and sirens pass outside. The tension, as they frame it, comes from hiding and avoiding discovery rather than from anyone actively running. They spend time on the moment when a spare phone is used. For the panel, that choice is tough to buy because someone working in UNIT should expect a burner phone to be monitored. The criticism allows that people under pressure can act oddly, then draws the line at characters behaving foolishly simply because the plot needs the clock to keep moving. JR, John, and Matt keep testing the story against basic common sense. They close by wondering whether the remaining story will turn lighter, more hopeful, and generally side with the Sea Devils. The discussion briefly checks the title Cold Blood before dismissing the idea that this story can simply repeat that pattern. The panel signs off ahead of the final episode, leaving predictions open until the next review.

As heard by us

A loose but specific panel review tests underwater promise, fugitive tension, and daft plot choices.

JR, John, and Matt review episodes three and four of The War Between the Land and the Sea, where the promised descent into the deep needs to become more than a tease.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Sea Devils at the bottom of the ocean, then you want someone asking why anyone thought a spare phone would stay invisible.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on