Exit

October 18, 2019·39 min·3 clips

Alex Blumberg secretly records his fears at 5 AM, wondering if selling Gimlet to Spotify will change everything he built.

1. StartUp Podcast's final-ever episode documents Gimlet Media's acquisition by Spotify, narrated by co-founder and host Alex Bloomberg. 2. Alex Bloomberg, a former non-profit worker, middle school teacher, and public radio journalist, co-founded Gimlet with Matt Lieber; both are present throughout the episode as the two principals navigating the deal. 3. The episode's core question is whether an acquisition that promises to keep everything the same while making everything better is a fantasy—and what it costs emotionally to find out. 4. After a trip to Stockholm to meet Spotify CEO Daniel Ek just before Thanksgiving, Alex and Matt receive a formal letter of intent proposing Spotify's acquisition of Gimlet at a price described as 'many tens of millions of dollars.' 5. Alex frames the money against his career history—non-profit, teaching, public radio—noting that running Gimlet he was actually earning less than in his public radio days, making the acquisition sum a figure he had never imagined as a realistic outcome. 6. Spotify sends a due diligence spreadsheet with over 100 rows of requests, including three years of 1099 forms, full bank account statements, and download data broken down by state for every show, prompting VP of Finance Jim Grau to describe moments of being 'physically out of breath.' 7. An all-day meeting with Spotify's podcast team—including Courtney, who ran their podcast division, Sheila, who led the acquisition, and Brian, head of sales—goes better than expected: Courtney repeatedly asks 'what is the thing keeping you from doing more work, and how can Spotify help clear the way?' 8. Gimlet co-founder Matt Lieber describes how answering Spotify's 30-question prep document—including 'how does the company discover new ideas?'—revealed how foreign a content company's creative process was to a technology platform. 9. Alex describes the existential nature of 'where do you get your new ideas?' appearing as one item in a 30-row spreadsheet: 'every day is a search for new ideas; anytime I find a good one, even after 25 years in the business, it still feels like a miracle.' 10. Executive coach Jerry Colonna, who had previously appeared on StartUp, directly challenges Alex's optimism, stating that 75-80% of acquisitions fail to generate more value than was spent, and identifying defensive posturing on both sides as the primary cause. 11. Colonna warns specifically about the gap between Daniel Ek's promises and the 3,000 Spotify employees below him who 'may or may not have opined' on the acquisition and are now being tasked with making it work. 12. Alex acknowledges the fundamental logical contradiction in his thinking: that the acquisition would simultaneously keep everything the same and make everything better, and describes starting to let go of that fantasy as the weeks progressed. 13. The merger agreement is signed at approximately 3am the night before Daniel Ek's quarterly earnings call, after a night of bleary-eyed lawyering in a conference room with Matt and Jim Grau. 14. The final 3am board meeting is held by phone; Alex notes he considered voting no 'just for laughs' but the formality of the ritual stopped him, and the vote is unanimous. 15. At the all-staff meeting the morning of the announcement, Alex thanks employees and breaks down crying; Matt—described as 'the emotionally unavailable one'—also cries, for the first time in the five years Alex has known him. 16. Gimlet editor Devin Taylor and Every Little Thing host Flora Lichtman both describe the experience as disorienting: Lichtman calls it 'a complete arranged marriage' and producer Phoebe Flanagan describes a nightmare about a $10 cantaloupe being the new lunch. 17. The episode blends late-night audio diaries, spousal conversations recorded in the living room, and retrospective narration, with Alex periodically noting the dates and circumstances of each recording. 18. The tone is reflective and candid—Alex is openly self-critical about his optimism, names his own contradictions, and lets silences and emotional moments run without cleanup. 19. People who built or sold a company, or who followed the original StartUp series, will find this a satisfying and honest close. 20. Listeners expecting a straightforward business-deal analysis or who have not heard earlier StartUp seasons may find the emotional texture heavier than the structural content.

As heard by us

A clear-eyed farewell to Gimlet, with the Spotify sale framed as a test of scale, control, and whether the work can stay intact.

StartUp's final episode treats Gimlet's sale to Spotify less as a victory lap than as a live management problem: what happens when the buyer looks serious, the team has rehearsed its answers, and the founders have to decide whether the work will survive the deal.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get the last Startup episode and the shaky, real-time feel of Gimlet's sale to Spotify.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from StartUp Podcast