WARNING: Cards Vanishing on Way to eBay & PSA (Mail Theft EXPOSED)

·36 min·3 clips

A collector's T206 Ty Cobb card vanished from a package en route to eBay authentication, exposing widespread mail theft.

The episode opens with a story about a collector, Sean from Victory Investments, who sold a high-value T206 Ty Cobb card on eBay and shipped it to eBay authentication, which is handled by PSA. The card was stolen from the package before arrival, despite an Apple AirTag being included. A postal inspector informed Sean that the Santa Ana post office in California receives 3,000 to 4,000 packages daily bound for PSA, all known to contain cards, and theft is rampant, potentially leading to an FBI investigation. Hosts Jeff, Teapot, and Haley then discuss preventive measures for shipping cards safely. Teapot shares his experience using registered mail with USPS for a $230 shipment to ensure chain of custody, while Haley suggests using larger boxes and double-boxing to deter theft. They advise against bubble mailers and USPS express envelopes, which are more vulnerable. The conversation shifts to industry news, starting with a lawsuit filed by Wildcard against Panini America, alleging antitrust practices where Panini pressured distributors to stop carrying Wildcard products. Teapot reflects on the irony, as Panini is currently suing Fanatics for similar claims, and discusses the pros and cons of competition in the card market. Next, the hosts analyze the 2025 football rookie card market, noting significant price drops for players like Cam Scataboo (down 45%) and Jackson Dart (down 18%) due to injuries and poor performance, questioning the class's investment potential. The episode concludes with a preview of an upcoming auction for a 2003 Exquisite Michael Jordan-Kobe Bryant dual logo man card owned by Nat Turner, expected to fetch a high price following a recent $12.9 million sale of a similar card. Throughout, the hosts engage in a casual, interview-style dialogue, blending personal anecdotes with industry insights.

As heard by us

A stolen T206 Ty Cobb card turns a valuable sale into a practical lesson in shipping risk.

A stolen pair of high-end cards turns the boom in sports-card collecting toward a less glamorous question: how safely value moves through the mail.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A high-end T206 Ty Cobb card is stolen before eBay authentication; you get the shipping lessons without the panic spiral.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Sports Card Investor