Split Zone Duo: College Football Podcast · Richard Johnson and Alex Kirshner

Anatomy of a Coaching Carousel: 2012

·28 min·2 clips

Urban Meyer's arrival at Ohio State professionalized the Big Ten to SEC standards, altering college football's course forever.

This episode of Split Zone Duo focuses on the 2012 college football coaching carousel, analyzing its long-term impacts on the sport. Hosts Alex Kirshner and Stephen Godfrey, both veteran college football journalists, examine the hires and fires from that offseason. The episode covers 28 FBS head coaching changes, categorizing eight as clearly good hires, seven as middling, ten as failures, and three as debatable. The discussion begins with Urban Meyer's move to Ohio State, which professionalized the Big Ten's recruiting to SEC standards and nationalized the Buckeyes' talent acquisition. Mike Leach's hiring at Washington State is highlighted as a perfect fit that boosted the program's national profile and birthed the "Pac-12 After Dark" phenomenon. The hosts detail Bill O'Brien's challenging tenure at Penn State, following Joe Paterno, amidst the ongoing Sandusky scandal fallout. Other notable situations mentioned include Carl Pelini at FAU, Norm Chow's return home, and the Todd Graham saga at Pitt. A key insight is that Meyer's arrival at Ohio State marked a seismic shift, directly leading to the Big Ten's modern competitiveness and national championship wins. The episode reveals that the 2012 carousel was defined by a wave of "celebrity coaches" in the Pac-12, fueled by new conference revenue, making programs like Arizona, Arizona State, and UCLA feel newly serious. It's noted that James Franklin was floated as a candidate for Penn State as early as 2011, years before he actually got the job. The hosts suggest the 2018 Washington State team, under Leach, could have made the College Football Playoff if not for a loss in the Apple Cup. The tone is conversational and deeply analytical, blending historical review with personal anecdotes from the hosts' careers. The style is educational but informal, featuring insider perspectives and "what-if" scenarios. This episode is ideal for fans who enjoy deep dives into college football history, coaching strategy, and program-building legacy. Listeners who prefer analysis of the current season or dislike historical retrospectives might want to skip it.

As heard by us

A sharp look at how Urban Meyer and James Franklin helped reshape Big Ten recruiting norms.

Split Zone Duo turns a coaching-cycle conversation into a clean look at how college football power gets built. It starts with the usual banter and snow, then settles into Urban Meyer and James Franklin.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want the coaching-hire math behind how Ohio State changed an era.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Split Zone Duo: College Football Podcast