Spiritual Misfits Podcast · Meeting Ground

Pub Theology: James Dobson, Charlie Kirk & Universalism

·59 min·3 clips

Mitch says he has a “universalist take” on James Dobson and Charlie Kirk.

Will Small opens by naming the people who end up on the fringes of faith. Mitch Forbes returns after a long gap and gives a quick update from Newcastle and New Lambton Uniting Church. The conversation starts with a faith crisis he did not plan. Mitch describes purity culture as part of what left him feeling badly wronged. He says there was no other option once he knew that story was not true or good. The talk then lands on eternal conscious torment. Mitch says there is zero evidence for it in the Bible. That becomes the hinge for the wider conversation. They ask what it would mean to decolonize church structures. The answer is not treated like a slogan. Instead, the episode keeps coming back to honesty and kindness as the path forward. The tone stays warm and a little loose. There is room for humor, and for the awkwardness of not having everything settled. The second half widens into free speech and public reaction. Mitch and Will point out the irony of people championing speech while still trying to get others punished for what they say. They note that the same punitive reflex shows up on the left as well. The conversation then sharpens around Charlie Kirk and the language of martyrdom. It compares that grief to the relative silence around Palestinian deaths and U.S. school shootings, which shows how selectively public outrage gets distributed. The episode leaves that tension open rather than resolving it, using a podcast conversation to hold theology, politics, and pastoral care in the same room.

As heard by us

A faith conversation about crisis, church reform, free speech, and public grief.

The episode begins in a faith crisis and stays with the hard questions: purity culture, the lack of biblical evidence for eternal conscious torment, and how church structures might be decolonized without losing kindness.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want faith talk that refuses neat answers.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Spiritual Misfits Podcast