Mark Edward Lender-War Without Mercy- Liberty or Death in the American Revolution

·24 min·2 clips

Historian Mark Edward Lender reveals how the American Revolution was a brutal civil war, not a storybook tale of noble patriotism.

Host Steve Richards interviews Mark Edward Lender, professor emeritus at Keene University and co-author of 'War Without Mercy: Liberty or Death in the American Revolution'. Lender explains the book was inspired by a paper he co-wrote with James Kirby Martin a decade ago, aiming to explore why the war became so violent, not just that it was violent. He notes the timing aligns with the 250th anniversary and Ken Burns' documentary. The book focuses on local-level conflicts in theaters like New Jersey, Pennsylvania, New York, and Connecticut, beyond the known brutality in the South. Lender describes how the Declaration of Independence served as a catalyst for violence by redefining patriots as an independent nation and loyalists as treasonous rebels. He asserts patriots started the violence to prevent counter-revolution, using local shunning, threats, and physical force. Lender emphasizes that 93% of the war was local, where rules of 'civilized warfare' didn't apply, leading to neighbor-against-neighbor brutality. He shares personal research insights from New Jersey, detailing areas like the 'neutral ground' that were uncontrollable and figures like Devil David Foreman. The book reveals the war involved conflicts between Native Americans and white settlers, and enslaved individuals seeking freedom. Lender hopes the book helps the public understand the revolution as a violent struggle endured by everyday people, not just political leaders. He mentions his co-author James Kirby Martin passed away after finishing the manuscript. In closing, Lender discusses his next project on the Battle of Minisink, exploring white loyalists serving under Mohawk leader Joseph Brant.

As heard by us

A measured discussion of Revolutionary War violence, local loyalties, and the fragile rules meant to restrain both.

Mark Edward Lender lowers the American Revolution from its heroic register and places it in the local struggles where fear, survival, and authority often decided behavior.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a Revolution stripped of pageantry, with local fear doing much of the historical work.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Speaking of Writers