Space Croutons · Goodwich Audio Productions

S5E16: Murder on the Oreo Express Part 2

May 24, 2025·38 min·3 clips

Abraham announces a murder has occurred on the Oreo Express and challenges everyone to find the killer among them.

The episode begins with a brief exchange between Sally and Cordy, indicating they are ready to dive into the story without a commercial break. Abraham then takes center stage, introducing himself and setting the scene for a murder mystery on the Oreo Express. He explains that a terrible event has happened and that the guilty party is still present, as no one has entered or left in the past 15 minutes. Abraham vouches for his own innocence, implying the killer is one of the other participants at the table. He formally welcomes everyone to 'Murder on the Oreo Express' and instructs them to find clues scattered around the car. Specifically, he tells them to look under their chairs for character details and alibis, emphasizing that they should show no one their cards and guard their secrets. The participants are tasked with playing detective, with a time limit of one hour until the train pulls into the station to identify and hand over the killer. The episode ends with the group beginning to reach for their clues, marking the start of the investigative process. The format blends narrative storytelling with interactive elements, creating a quirky, science fiction atmosphere. Recurring themes include mystery, collaboration, and suspense, as listeners are drawn into the puzzle. Key moments include Abraham's dramatic announcement, the revelation of hidden clues, and the imposition of a time constraint. The episode is part of a series where Curdy hosts stories of strange experiences, and this installment continues a multi-part murder mystery arc. The rustic, down-home feel is maintained through the conversational tone and structured gameplay.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Space Croutons