Songwriter Theory Podcast: Learn Songwriting And Write Meaningful Lyrics and Songs · Joseph Vadala

This Songwriting Attitude Has To Stop

·46 min·3 clips

Joseph Vidal says the core songwriting attitude is "cutting corners and doing the bare minimum."

Joseph Vidal opens by calling out a songwriting mindset he thinks does real damage. He says it shows up in different forms again and again. The target is the belief that songs should come together quickly, cleanly, and with little struggle. He pushes back on that idea hard. Some songs do arrive fast, and those stories stick because they are unusual. Most songs, he argues, take far more time than people want to admit. He talks about writers spending an hour on one line or months on a four line section. To him, that is not failure. It is just craft. He also warns against the other trap. He does not think every song should be chased forever in the name of perfection. At some point, you have to decide a song is good enough and move on. He treats that as part of the work, not a shortcut. The episode keeps coming back to that balance between patience and overthinking. Vidal says the hard part is knowing when to stop revising. He then shares a practical habit he uses while writing lyrics. He keeps a single Google Doc as a running archive for different lyric versions. He usually writes by hand first, then moves the material into that document. The goal is to keep the work visible and easy to return to. He also suggests that when songs start to feel stale, the problem may be the opening rather than the writer’s imagination. Changing how a song begins can reopen the whole thing. Near the end, he reminds listeners that other songwriters and musicians can be discouraging. That does not mean the work is not worth doing. He closes by urging listeners to stay discouraged by the right things, not by writing itself.

As heard by us

A blunt reminder that the rare fast song is not the standard.

The episode pushes back on the idea that songs should be finished in an hour or two, and it does so without much fuss. Joseph Vidal treats the fast, almost magical songwriting story as real, but rare.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you think a song should arrive fast, this one resets the clock on that expectation and slows the panic.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Songwriter Theory Podcast: Learn Songwriting And Write Meaningful Lyrics and Songs