Song by Song

Woe, Blood Money, Tom Waits [312]

·23 min·2 clips
Why does a one-minute Tom Waits fragment from a murder play captivate hosts who debate if it's even a complete song?
Martin, Sam and Pete begin with an immediate, fairly uncomplicated love for “Woe.” It is short, direct and performed so beautifully that finding fault with it is not easy. Then doubt starts to creep in. The recording audibly moves onward, so they wonder whether this is really a self-contained song or a fragment made to serve the play around it. That question proves more interesting than the answer. A small piece can break up an album precisely because it is not another fully formed track doing what listeners expect. The arrangement is barely there. Two string players sit behind the lead vocal, making so little sound that the instruments themselves seem close to breaking apart. Waits’s voice has the same fragile quality. Its familiar cracks leave the performance hovering near disappearance, and the group hears that as exactly right for the material. Eventually, the conversation comes down to subtraction. Make everything quieter and, in a slightly backwards way, the emotional effect gets louder. Their interval choice takes that idea somewhere else. Kitty White’s version of “Plain Gold Ring” is built around a repeating hand-drum figure, with nearly everything else left to the singer. The rhythm adds urgency, but it also leaves White completely exposed. She has to carry the melody, lyrics, implied harmony and emotional force herself. An arrangement like that takes confidence. The group compares her control with the singer discussed the previous week, who could pull meaning from every line and word, while noting that White lands in a different place. The conversation wanders, as it tends to, but keeps circling back. “Woe” and “Plain Gold Ring” show what happens when performers strip away the usual support and trust the voice to hold the centre.

As heard by us

Martin, Sam and Pete find the weight of Tom Waits's "Woe" in near-silent strings and a voice that keeps breaking apart.

Tom Waits's "Woe," from Bloodimony, rewards attention to how little it uses. Martin, Sam and Pete focus on two string players barely making a noise and a lead vocal that keeps breaking up, hearing a performance poised at the edge of decay.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You'll hear the hosts unpack how Tom Waits makes a short fragment feel powerful by keeping it close to collapse.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on