SmartLess · Jason Bateman, Sean Hayes, Will Arnett

"Maggie Gyllenhaal"

March 23, 2026·1 hr 2 min·4 clips

Maggie Gyllenhaal wrote a scene on a plane that felt so dangerous she looked over her shoulder.

1. SmartLess hosts Sean Hayes, Jason Bateman, and Will Arnett interview Maggie Gyllenhaal about her second feature film as director, The Bride, and her evolving career. 2. Maggie Gyllenhaal is the daughter of director Stephen Gyllenhaal and writer Naomi Foner; her brother Jake Gyllenhaal previously appeared on SmartLess; her husband is actor Peter Sarsgaard. 3. The episode's central thread is Maggie's transition from acclaimed actor to director and what she finds more fulfilling about running a set than performing on one. 4. Maggie explains that directing allows her to 'make space for everyone else to offer what they want' rather than protecting her own small corner of a scene as an actor. 5. She says she did not allow herself to imagine directing for years because 'there weren't any other women doing it' — she wasn't aware of Agnes Varda in high school and saw actresses, not directors, as her models. 6. Her mother Naomi Foner directed her first film as a grandmother, which Maggie describes as 'a total wild departure' — she believes her mother may be one of the only people to have directed a debut film at that life stage. 7. Maggie wrote and directed The Lost Daughter (2021) in 26 days in Greece, where the crew lacked basic roles like a props master, forcing her to manage a key doll prop herself. 8. She describes being 'terrified' before The Bride in a way she was not before The Lost Daughter, because the second film involved a larger budget, a longer schedule, Christian Bale and Penelope Cruz and Annette Bening, and her own full knowledge of what could go wrong. 9. The Bride's origin came from seeing a full-forearm tattoo of the Bride of Frankenstein at a party, which led her to watch the 1935 film for the first time and find the character appears for only two minutes without speaking. 10. After reading Mary Shelley's novel, Maggie reframes Frankenstein not as a monster but as someone who 'literally hangs out in a barn next to people speaking French and learns French in a couple of days' — self-teaching, lonely, and fully human. 11. The film's dramatic question is: what did the Bride herself want, having been dug up from a grave without her consent and presented with a man she didn't choose? 12. Maggie says Elsa Lanchester's performance in the 1935 original communicates 'fuck no' without words, and she wanted to explore what it looks like when that refusal is also entangled with 'an epic love story.' 13. On set with The Lost Daughter, Maggie spoke to Jesse Buckley using the same introspective, emotional language she would want from a director herself — and Buckley absorbed it naturally. 14. Attempting the same approach with Olivia Colman produced an immediate 'What the fuck are you talking about?' response, teaching Maggie to diagnose each actor's preferred communication register before giving notes. 15. Annette Bening on The Bride wanted no more than one note at a time; when Maggie arrived with multiple layered observations, Bening 'made that very clear' she wanted only the top priority. 16. An unnamed actor on The Lost Daughter yelled at Maggie mid-shoot; her immediate reaction was 'I've been him, I get it' — she recognized it as a performer trying to break through to something alive rather than personal hostility. 17. The episode has a warm, loose, anecdote-driven format; Sean's theater stories and Will's interjections provide comedic counterpoint to Maggie's more considered answers. 18. Jason asks consistently detailed craft questions — about auditioning vs. first-day actor surprises, about emotional flexibility for writer-directors — while Will and Sean provide punchlines. 19. Listeners who enjoy candid filmmaking craft discussion, particularly around the director-actor relationship and creative fear, will find substantive material alongside the jokes. 20. Listeners expecting primarily comedy banter or those unfamiliar with The Lost Daughter, The Bride, or Maggie Gyllenhaal's work may find the middle sections slow.

As heard by us

Maggie Gyllenhaal makes directing sound collaborative, nerve-wracking, and much less puppet-based than Hollywood sometimes pretends.

Maggie Gyllenhaal turns a SmartLess visit into a neat little argument against puppet acting. Her best point is simple: a movie gets better when actors bring their minds and hearts into the room, instead of just performing whatever the director dreamed up alone like some…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A director talks about making room for actors to surprise her, then protecting the moments that feel special.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from SmartLess