324: هل أنت مكتئب فعلًا

·1 hr 49 min·5 clips

Dr. Ahmed Shaya argues that the origin of humans is illness, not health, questioning the entire premise of psychological medicine.

This episode of 'Fingan' features host Abdulrahman Abumalih in conversation with Dr. Ahmed Shaya, a professor of psychological medicine at a Saudi university and president of the Saudi Association of Psychological Sciences. Dr. Shaya opens with a provocative claim that the origin of people is illness, not health, setting a critical tone for the discussion. They delve into statistics showing only 28% of Saudis with psychological disorders receive treatment, attributing this to lack of services, stigma, and unawareness. The host and guest explore the line between normal life stressors and clinical disorders, emphasizing that psychological pressure is part of life unless it severely impacts multiple areas over time. A significant portion critiques the self-development and positive psychology movements, arguing they create unrealistic expectations of perpetual happiness and perfection, leading to harm. Dr. Shaya explains the challenges of psychological diagnosis, noting its reliance on subjective reports rather than objective tests like in physical medicine, which increases error rates. They discuss the risk of overdiagnosis, where normal behaviors are pathologized, especially in private clinics driven by insurance systems. The conversation touches on cultural specifics, such as depression in Saudi Arabia often presenting with physical complaints rather than emotional ones, questioning the universal application of Western diagnostic manuals like the DSM. Dr. Shaya advises against seeking psychological treatment unless symptoms are severe, persistent, and debilitating, warning of potential harm from unnecessary interventions. The episode concludes with reflections on the role of media and campaigns in mental health awareness, balancing the need to reduce stigma without encouraging overdiagnosis.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from فنجان مع عبدالرحمن أبومالح