Sexuality Archives - KDA Keeping Democracy Alive Podcast & Radio Show · Burt Cohen

Gender Identity: Is it Fixed or Changeable?

·58 min·5 clips
Why the 'born this way' argument for LGBTQ+ rights is limiting and harmful in clinical practice.
The episode starts with a broad political claim about fear and how it gets used. Cohen argues that successful autocrats know how fear of the other can be turned quickly into hate. He moves through examples of that tactic, including the manufactured fear around child abuse and the long history of racialized panic. The discussion then narrows toward gender and sexuality. From there, the conversation asks why trans people have become such a potent target. It treats that backlash as part of a longer pattern of fear and moral panic, not a one-off flare-up. Avi Sakotopoulou explains that the familiar story about sex, hormones, phenotype, and gender is not as settled as it sounds. The discussion presses on the gap between what is assigned at birth and what people actually come to live as. A key argument is that gender does not just appear fully formed. It has to be learned, inhabited, and made one's own. That claim is extended beyond trans experience. Even people described as cisgender do work to recognize the gender they were assigned and to experience it as theirs. The episode treats that process as psychic, social, relational, and institutional rather than natural or automatic. That makes the argument broader than a single identity debate. Cohen responds by drawing on the gender scripts he grew up with in the 1950s. He recalls the hard version of masculinity taught to boys and the narrow domestic ideal offered to girls. The conversation connects those old scripts to larger systems of power. Cohen also returns to racism and white supremacy as part of the same wider history of sorting people into hierarchies. Throughout, the show keeps returning to the idea that common-sense ideas about gender can hide political purpose. What looks like tradition can also be discipline. The pacing is measured, and the host lets the guest develop the point at length. That gives the episode room to build an argument instead of just chasing a takeaway. At times the framing is so broad that the interview feels more declarative than exploratory. Still, the central distinction stays vivid: gender is not just assigned, it is lived into. The episode also resists treating identity as simple or purely self-evident. Instead, it asks how a sense of gender is supported, recognized, and blocked by the culture around it. That makes the conversation useful for listeners trying to understand why these debates get so charged. It is not only about identity; it is about who gets to define reality. The final note is one of curiosity and freedom. Cohen closes by stressing that openness to this subject can add to human freedom rather than threaten it. The show names the book Gender Without Identity and identifies Sakotopoulou as its co-author with Ann Pellegrini, published by NYU Press. By the end, the episode has made a case that gender is not a private technicality but a social field shaped by power, memory, and fear. It asks listeners to reconsider how much of what feels natural has been taught.

As heard by us

A serious political conversation about gender, fear, and how identity is made.

This episode treats gender identity as a political and historical question rather than a slogan. It moves from the fear aimed at trans people to the sharper point that cisgender identity is also learned, inhabited, and made one's own.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a serious conversation about fear in politics and how gender is made and lived.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on