Sex Within Marriage Podcast : Exploring Married Sexuality from a Christian Perspective · Jay Dee - Marriage Educator

SWM 137 – Why we don’t spank our children

·18 min·1 clip
JD argues that teaching children to fear their parents creates better liars who run from trouble rather than better people who seek help.
JD opens by picking up a Gary Thomas Substack post on discipline versus punishment and asking whether a person's view of hell changes how they parent. He says the question matters because he and Christina do not believe hell is eternal torture, and that conviction has shaped how they think about authority, discipline, and family life. From there he moves into a broader defense of not spanking children. His point is blunt: violence is not how you teach a child not to use violence. He makes room for narrow exceptions, like martial arts training or immediate self-defense, but treats punishment-driven hitting as something else entirely. JD argues that parents who want children to fear them often end up raising children who hide, lie, and run away when they are in trouble. That, he says, keeps children from coming to their parents when they actually need help. He contrasts that with the kind of home he wanted to build, where mistakes come into the open instead of being buried. When his children make bad choices, he says, they come to him for help and forgiveness rather than bracing for punishment. He draws a line between consequences and punishments and says consequences can sometimes be negotiated with the child, because children eventually need to learn how to set their own consequences around bad decisions and make their own rules. He also notes that his children sometimes think he is too lenient and may call him out later for not holding them accountable. Younger children still try to hide or deceive at times. He does not soften that. He connects it to Adam and Eve as a familiar pattern of human avoidance. The closing move is practical rather than abstract. He cites studies suggesting that 70 to 90 percent of parents still spank their children, which he uses to explain why non-spanking parents can feel isolated. He then invites disagreement, questions, and stories from readers, and he also invites agreement so people who choose this path do not feel alone. The episode ends with a reminder to take the survey, including the one question about spanking.

As heard by us

A plainspoken case for discipline that builds trust instead of fear.

An argument about spanking is treated as a wider question about what children learn from fear, and JD extends it into Christian theology, violence, and trust at home.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a Christian argument against spanking, this one takes its time.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on