Seriously Mysterious - Missing Persons, Unsolved Murders & Historical True Crime · John Lordan - Respectful True Crime Content Creator, Advocate and Host

Where is Samantha Fiddler?

·21 min

The episode opens from the point where Samantha Fiddler’s trail starts to go cold. It begins with the relationship around Teddy, which comes across as unstable and worrying. A friend named John enters the story after meeting the pair at a wrestling event. He is invited to a match in Orlando. Samantha and Teddy pick up John from the airport. John notices them arguing in the car. When they reach the motel, he gets out and heads for his room. As he climbs the stairs, he looks back and sees the argument still going on. Teddy hits Samantha. John runs back down to break it up. Teddy tells John that it is not what it looks like. John leaves with the sense that Samantha needed to get out of that relationship. The episode then turns to Samantha’s contact with family, friends, and her children. Even without a phone, she stays in touch for a while. That communication gets less frequent as the weeks go by. One of the clearest details comes from Samantha’s friend Jamie. Samantha calls from a blocked number. She sounds rushed. She says she needs to get home and that she is kind of stuck in Florida. The episode also raises claims about videos and editing work connected to Pottery Barn content, but it does not confirm whether Samantha appeared in those videos or was asked to. The narrative stays careful about what can be proven and keeps returning to the same confirmed details: the argument in the car, the motel confrontation, the blocked-number call, and the gradual drop-off in communication.

As heard by us

A careful reconstruction of Samantha Fiddler's disappearance, strongest when it stays close to the known trail.

The episode traces Samantha Fiddler's disappearance through the people and places around her, and it is strongest when it stays with the documented details instead of forcing a tidy explanation.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Follow the trail from a motel argument to a blocked-number call.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify