Serial Killer Podcast Documentary · Peter Jesse

American Justice： A Small Town Unravels After a Shocking Crime in the Woods

·43 min·3 clips

April’s phone and a firefighter’s video place the motorcycle at the same spot at the same time.

1. Serial Killer Podcast Documentary covers the disappearance and killing of 14-year-old April Millsap on the Macomb Orchard Trail in Armada, Michigan. 2. The episode uses Megan as the opening narrator and then shifts to police, April’s mother Jennifer Millsap, her stepdad David, and investigators who explain why the case mattered to Armada. 3. The episode asks how April’s phone, witnesses, and a motorcycle helped identify the person who killed her. 4. April leaves home in the summer to walk the family dog Penny on the trail, which her family describes as a routine trip around 5:00 to 5:30 PM. 5. Nearly two hours later, a young couple finds a distressed dog and then a lifeless body off the trail in the woods. 6. Officers describe April’s ripped clothing, the shoes on either side of a ditch, and a clear shoe imprint across her face and neck. 7. The medical examiner rules the death as asphyxiation and blunt force trauma, and police also collect a rape kit because of the condition of her clothes. 8. Jennifer Millsap reports April missing, and Austin says April texted him, “I think I almost got kidnapped” at 6:28 PM. 9. Investigators question Austin because he says he was in a cemetery and later at a fast-food restaurant, while surveillance video shows him at a drive-thru around 6:30 PM. 10. The police chief says Armada had not recorded a homicide in 41 years, which heightens the town’s fear and outrage. 11. Officers release April’s photo, set up a tip line, and search for her phone and backpack because both items could contain fingerprints or DNA. 12. One of the first big tips describes a white van, but the builder who owns it brings it in and is cleared. 13. Other witnesses describe an older man on a blue-and-white motorcycle, and one sketch artist drawing leads officers to James Van Callis. 14. A tracking truck and a search dog locate April’s cell phone in an overgrown thicket by the road. 15. The phone’s exercise app shows April speeding up, entering the woods, and moving in a zigzag pattern for about 10 minutes. 16. A firefighter’s home security camera captures the motorcycle passing at the same time the phone is moving past that house, which officers treat as major evidence. 17. James Van Callis tells police he was in Armada on his motorcycle, but officers say his shoe tread does not match the imprint found on April. 18. James’s girlfriend Crystal Stadler later says he wore Air Nikes, cleaned his shoes with a sock and hand sanitizer, and changed after the night of the killing. 19. The episode plays as a police documentary with interviews, timeline reconstruction, witness statements, and repeated emphasis on surveillance, cell data, and forensic comparison. 20. People interested in small-town true-crime investigations and phone-to-video timeline work would fit this episode best, while listeners wanting lighthearted banter would likely skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Serial Killer Podcast Documentary