Scratch a Track: Music Review and Commentary Podcast · The Dude and Grimm Show

Led Zeppelin IV - Album Review

·47 min·3 clips

The hosts debate the Stairway to Heaven lawsuit and say the descending riff is “undeniable” and “the same.”

Untitled is the first argument. The Dude and Grim keep circling that point because everyone calls it Led Zeppelin 4 or Zoso, but the blank title was the move. Led Zeppelin 3 is hanging over the conversation too. They read the choice as the band answering a lukewarm reception, even though they admit the criticism never fully makes sense to them because they still like that record. Then the episode loosens up. If a band has private-jet money, they joke, it can follow ridiculous studio instincts and still somehow land on the right take. The remixing detour gets messy in a good way. They riff on the sort of spending a massive band could rationalize, then come back to the real delay: the cover, the missing title, and a record company that sounds deeply uneasy. That nervousness is the fun part. The band is ignoring normal release logic right before putting out something that becomes almost impossible to argue with. Then double-album talk kicks in. Down by the Seaside, Night Flight, Boogie with Stu, and an early No Quarter make the case that a bigger version was at least plausible. The Dude and Grim still land on restraint. Stairway and When the Levee Breaks already make the album feel heavy enough, and stretching it starts to sound less like abundance and more like a headache. The single album wins. That becomes the spine of the discussion: the mystery works because the band leaves things out, even with more material nearby. The close gets a little sharper. They treat the album as a nasty answer to critics, mention Metacritic praise, and take a quick shot at Pitchfork for refusing to join the line. Radio comes back into it too, especially in Grim's final scratch, where the songs' life beyond the record seems to matter. The episode ends loose, with The Dude and Grim pointing listeners toward their other Led Zeppelin scratches and leaving the album overtalked but still worth arguing about.

As heard by us

A loose, conversational defense of why Led Zeppelin IV's untitled release still matters.

Led Zeppelin IV is treated as a deliberate, untitled move, and that choice gives the episode its shape. The hosts spend time on the label's hesitation, the possibility of a double set, and the case for keeping it to one album.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a chatty, no-priest-hat take on an untitled Led Zeppelin IV?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Scratch a Track: Music Review and Commentary Podcast