Scratch a Track: Music Review and Commentary Podcast · The Dude and Grimm Show

Is Band of Gypsys by Jimi Hendrix the greatest live album?

·40 min·2 clips

“Machine Gun” is the standout, and the hosts call it one of the best live songs ever recorded.

1. Scratch a Track: Music Review and Commentary Podcast debates whether Jimi Hendrix’s Band of Gypsys belongs among the greatest live albums. 2. The hosts, Dude and Grim, frame the record as Hendrix’s first album with Billy Cox on bass and Buddy Miles on drums, which matters because it marks a lineup change from the Jimi Hendrix Experience. 3. They ask whether Band of Gypsys is “the best live album of all time” and treat that question as the episode’s core hook. 4. The conversation compares the album with Johnny Cash at Folsom Prison, Frampton Comes Alive, MC5’s Kick Out the Jams, Leon Live, and James Brown Live at the Apollo. 5. They also mention The Band’s The Last Waltz, The Who Live at Leeds, Pink Floyd Pulse, and Led Zeppelin BBC Sessions as part of the live-album canon. 6. The hosts explain that Band of Gypsys was pulled from recordings across four Fillmore East shows over two days, not from one uninterrupted concert. 7. They say the album became part of a legal settlement involving Ed Chalpin and Capitol Records, and Hendrix later said, “we owed the record company an album.” 8. The episode notes that Hendrix was out of tune on some material and that Eddie Kramer described mixing the record as a challenge. 9. They add that some tracks were trimmed, including “Changes” and “We Gotta Live Together,” because the release was edited down from longer performances. 10. The hosts highlight “Who Knows” as a strong opener, describing its funky groove and the back-and-forth vocals between Hendrix and Buddy Miles. 11. They single out “Machine Gun” as the track everyone talks about, and they discuss its twelve-and-a-half-minute length as a major reason the album is remembered. 12. The conversation emphasizes Buddy Miles’ drumming on “Machine Gun,” with the drums described as sounding like a machine gun. 13. They quote Bono’s description that Hendrix “put Vietnam into the amplifier,” using it to capture the track’s sound and mood. 14. The hosts note that Hendrix seemed statuesque during the recording, which they connect to his awareness that the tapes were being used for the album. 15. They say Hendrix wanted the final record to include Buddy Miles songs, not just his own writing, and they describe that choice as part of the project’s shape. 16. The episode points out that Buddy Miles’ vocals are especially strong on “Changes,” “Power to Love,” and “We Gotta Live Together.” 17. The tone is conversational and ranking-driven, with Dude and Grim moving from album history into track-by-track commentary. 18. The format mixes opinion, trivia, and short technical notes about editing, tape selection, and live recording limitations. 19. Listeners who enjoy Hendrix, live albums, and 1960s rock history will likely enjoy this episode. 20. Listeners who want a short, purely studio-album analysis may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Scratch a Track: Music Review and Commentary Podcast