Scotland Outdoors · BBC Radio Scotland

Winter Climbing with Guy Robertson

·34 min·3 clips
A climber attempted a route for 19 years, with each failure etched as a vivid, memorable experience.
Guy Robertson makes a strong case for winter climbing as more than a pastime. He treats it as something deeply nourishing, with a physical and psychological freedom that sits apart from an increasingly sterile, risk-averse world. The book is part of the story. Together with Hamish Frost, he has put together The Great Mixed Climbs of Scotland, a survey of routes with names that sound at once poetic and slightly dangerous: White Magic, Trail of Tears, Gully of the Gods, Messiah, and The Screaming. That is not an accidental list. The titles point to a style of climbing that is steep, winter-only, and serious enough to feel like a small frontier before anyone even clips a rope. The practical appeal comes through clearly. Robertson says a winter day in the hills usually starts in the morning and ends at night without the acclimatisation or permit logistics that come with bigger mountains, and that stripped-back rhythm gives the whole thing a sharper edge. It is a lot for a relatively small cliff. He argues that there are not many places in Europe where you can still go into the mountains and climb steep, hard, winter-only rock in this way, which is why Scotland keeps its strange and stubborn place in the climbing imagination. The Alps do not escape comparison. From the outside, Scotland can look like a wild frontier to climbers used to cable cars, guides, helicopters, and other ways of smoothing the job down to size. Here, you cannot ride to the bottom of the route, and you have to place all of your own protection. That changes the mindset and means you need someone else who wants the same kind of day. The harder grades, especially around grade six and above, are not impossible in the abstract, but they are harder to find somebody for on a regular basis because the outlook has to match as much as the fitness. The interview keeps its feet on the ground. It moves through risk, access, and what the landscape actually asks of people, then lets Robertson answer with the kind of conviction that comes from long experience rather than grand statements. The mood stays practical and appreciative. By the end, the episode feels like a brisk walk into serious country, with enough detail to make the hardship understandable and enough admiration to show why the climbing still matters.

As heard by us

A grounded case for winter climbing as a place-specific kind of freedom and challenge.

The piece treats winter climbing as a hard, honest kind of freedom, and Guy Robertson makes that case well. Working with Hamish Frost on The Great Mixed Climbs of Scotland, the discussion moves through route names like White Magic, Trail of Tears, Gully of the Gods, Messiah, and…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when you want Scotland at its steepest and most uncompromising.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on