Science Rules! with Bill Nye · Stitcher & Bill Nye

Our Fishy Ancestors Grew a Pair (of Legs)

·55 min·5 clips

Neil Shubin reveals how his team found the flat-headed Tiktaalik fossil that bridges fish and land animals.

Bill Nye and science writer Corey S. Powell welcome Professor Neil Shubin, whose books include Your Inner Fish, to discuss the discovery of Tiktaalik roseae, one of the most important transitional fossils ever found. Shubin recalls being a graduate student when he saw a slide showing a massive gap in the fossil record between fish and land-dwelling tetrapods and deciding that filling that gap would be his life's work. He explains how fossil hunters triangulate using three criteria: rocks of the right geological age (in this case, late Devonian, 375 million years ago), rocks formed in the right environments (ancient river delta systems rather than ocean or volcanic deposits), and rocks that are actually accessible and not buried under modern development. This search led Shubin's team to Ellesmere Island in the Canadian Arctic, where they spent several field seasons before finding Tiktaalik. Shubin explains that fish already had lungs long before the transition to land -- lungfish alive today in Florida and southern Africa demonstrate this -- and that gills and lungs coexisted as dual systems. The transition to land was not a single dramatic leap but a gradual accumulation of features: Tiktaalik had a flat head, a neck (unique among fish), fins with internal bones including a proto-wrist, and could likely prop itself up on the bottom of shallow water. Shubin emphasizes that Tiktaalik is not a missing link in the sense of a perfect half-fish half-amphibian, but rather a snapshot of one evolutionary stage in a long continuum. The conversation explores what this means for understanding the human body: our limb bones, wrists, and even aspects of our inner ear trace directly back to fish anatomy. Shubin describes the thrill of fieldwork in the Arctic and reflects on what it means to hold a creature that connects us physically to life 375 million years ago.

As heard by us

Bill Nye turns the shift from water to land into a clear, question-led discussion of evolution and anatomy.

Bill Nye and Corey S. Powell move through a familiar evolutionary puzzle: how an aquatic transitional life form could adapt to land, and what that reveals about animal body plans.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the origin story of legs, told in Bill Nye's conversational science-show voice instead of museum-label jargon.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Science Rules! with Bill Nye