Science Fiction Book Review Podcast · Luke Burrage

SFBRP #571 – Becky Chambers – The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet – Wayfarers #1

·1 hr 17 min·5 clips

Luke says Kizzy's dialogue became the immediate reason he stopped rereading the novel.

1. Science Fiction Book Review Podcast #571 focuses on Becky Chambers's The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet and whether it still belongs on the SFBRP must-reads list. 2. Luke Burridge hosts with Juliana, who joins as co-host and reader, and both matter because they compare different readings of the same book. 3. The episode asks whether a novel that once seemed good enough on first read still works more than 10 years later. 4. Luke says he reread The City of Last Chances, Inversions, A Time of Changes, and then returned to Becky Chambers's novel. 5. He places the book beside other list candidates such as The Forever War, Gateway, The Hunger Games, Starship Troopers, and A Psalm for the Wild-Built. 6. Luke explains that the SFBRP must-reads list is meant to track books that are still good reads, not just historically important titles. 7. He says the list also includes books that are foundational or influential, even when they do not fully hold up as stories or characters. 8. Juliana argues that the list is useful because it covers different kinds of science fiction, including mythic, religious, and fantasy-adjacent material. 9. Luke says his reread of The Long Way to a Small, Angry Planet stalled because Kizzy's dialogue became hard to read. 10. He notes that Neil had made the same complaint in a 2017 comment after Luke's earlier review. 11. Luke says this reread also exposed other problems in the writing, the storytelling, and the science-fiction worldbuilding. 12. He says curiosity carried him through the first read nine years earlier, but this time he remembered many of the major plot turns. 13. Luke names Rosemary's father as a weapons dealer and recalls setup for a character getting a body. 14. Juliana responds that the novel feels overstuffed because it mixes pirates, politics, war, bombs, robots, and an energy weapon. 15. She still points to the alien species, the worldbuilding, and the found-family dynamic as parts she values. 16. Luke says the relationships on the ship feel unreal to him because the characters are mostly told they get along rather than tested by conflict. 17. Juliana offers a different reading of the writing by describing how a small room, curtains, or a dress can evoke a feeling without detailed explanation. 18. She says that style can give her space from the emotional labor she already does in daily life by reading other people's moods and movements. 19. People who like cozy science fiction, found-family stories, and low-conflict character ensembles will get the most from this episode. 20. People who want tightly plotted, high-drama, or heavily explained science fiction may skip it.

As heard by us

A blunt, useful argument about cozy science fiction and why charm does not always equal craft.

Luke Burridge and Juliana use the review to pin cozy science fiction against the demands of craft, and the best part is the way they stay with the small stuff.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a frank take on cozy science fiction from two people thinking out loud, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Science Fiction Book Review Podcast