San Jose Hockey Now Podcast · Sheng Peng, Keegan McNally, Bleav

Sharks Top 10 Prospects of 2025-26 | EP 103 Musty, Lund Rising?

·2 hr 37 min·5 clips

Dan Boyle reveals how embracing risk and playing his own game saved his career after four years of struggle.

This episode of the San Jose Hockey Now Podcast features hosts Sheng Peng, Keegan, and Dan Boyle debating the San Jose Sharks' potential captaincy and discussing prospect Jack Thompson. Dan Boyle, a former NHL defenseman with an 18-year career, provides a player's perspective on leadership. The central debate revisits whether Barclay Goodrow or Tyler Toffoli is a more suitable captain, with Mario Ferraro also mentioned as a candidate. The hosts recap Goodrow's recent two-year, $3.6 million contract and his being waived by the New York Rangers. They note Toffoli specifically chose to sign in San Jose as a free agent, expressing a desire for stability, while Goodrow was claimed off waivers. Boyle emphasizes that outsiders cannot know the dynamics inside the locker room, which is the most critical factor. He cites his experience with Tampa Bay, where 37-year-old Tim Taylor served as captain while playing about eight minutes per night. Boyle personally advocates for not naming a captain this season, instead assigning alternate captains and waiting for Macklin Celebrini to mature. A key insight is Boyle's argument that a captain's on-ice minutes are less important than his presence in the lineup and his voice in the room. He states the captain must be a "glue guy" who holds teammates accountable and can communicate between players and coaches. The hosts discuss how Goodrow's perceived work ethic and shot-blocking are actions any player can emulate, unlike Toffoli's natural scoring talent. Boyle also expresses respect for Goodrow's professionalism in playing hard for San Jose after an unplanned arrival. The conversation shifts to defenseman Jack Thompson, acquired from Tampa Bay, who faces a crowded blue line and questions about being a "tweener" who doesn't excel enough offensively or defensively to demand a roster spot. The tone is conversational and debate-driven, featuring friendly disagreements and personal anecdotes about music and dating. Listeners who enjoy insider hockey debates about leadership, roster construction, and prospect evaluation will appreciate this episode. Those seeking hard news updates or pure game analysis might find the extended captaincy discussion less engaging.

As heard by us

Loose Sharks banter that settles into the preseason prospect list, the Gaudreau-Toffoli debate, and Misa's debut.

This Sharks episode starts with loose banter, then settles into the main business: the top 10 Sharks prospects at preseason, another pass at the Bronco Gaudreau versus Tyler Toffoli debate, Dan Boyle's perspective, and Michael Misa's preseason debut.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the Sharks prospect board and a fresh read on the roster puzzle.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from San Jose Hockey Now Podcast