RuPalp's Podrace: A Queer Star Wars & Pop Culture Podcast · RuPalp's Podrace

The Mystery Spotcast: Humans of Destiel (FEED DROP)

·1 hr 20 min·4 clips

Both shows canonized gay relationships in the most homophobic way possible.

It starts with a joke. The hosts open by batting away the idea of a Supernatural reboot directed by Ryan Murphy, then introduce Superhell, also known as The Mystery Spotcast, a rewatch podcast from two recovering fans who are choosing to do this to themselves on purpose. The mission is pretty straightforward. They plan to work through the entire series one episode at a time, though they admit that 327 episodes will probably force some regrouping once the show gets especially dense. They also say right away that you do not need prior Supernatural knowledge to keep up. Then the pilot arrives. The conversation moves into the opening family sequence, where a mother says good night to baby Sammy, hears him crying, checks on him, and realizes the house is already slipping into nightmare mode. It turns grim fast. The father is asleep on the couch, the mother ends up burning on the ceiling above the crib, and the hosts sit with how ridiculous and horrifying that image is at the same time. The blood detail lands too. As the father reaches toward the baby, blood drips onto his hand, giving the scene one of those tiny horror beats the hosts clearly think does a lot of heavy lifting. Then Dean gets the order. The dad tells him to take his baby brother and run, and the episode turns that survival beat into the first major foreshadowing of the brothers' whole series-long dynamic. Nobody is treating the fire like a joke. The house burns, the firefighters show up, and the hosts point out how sad it is to watch the family sitting outside afterward, with Dad looking like he has already entered his Joker era. But the reading keeps moving. What makes the discussion work is the way it keeps switching between joke energy and real emotional reaction, so the pilot's opening disaster never gets treated like throwaway trivia. The name fits. They explain the title as a joke about feeling like Sam Winchester trapped at the Mystery Spot, because once this rewatch starts, apparently nobody is getting out.

As heard by us

A loose, funny rewatch that keeps coming back to the pilot's opening family-horror scene.

This episode starts with a Ryan Murphy reboot joke, then settles into a loose but steady rewatch of Supernatural. Ollie and Claudia keep the pace relaxed, but they do not drift far from the work at hand.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a Supernatural rewatch led by two recovering fans, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from RuPalp's Podrace: A Queer Star Wars & Pop Culture Podcast