Running His Race Podcast with Christian Run Coach, Elizabeth · Coach Elizabeth

Running Without Losing Your Identity with Conni Mahoney

·53 min·5 clips
Conni realized running is what she does, not who she is, after God challenged her identity.
Coach Elizabeth introduces Connie as her first trail athlete and sets the scene for a conversation about running, faith, and identity. Connie says she lives in Crested Butte, Colorado, and describes herself as a wife, a mom, a trail runner, a wildlife photographer, and a co-host with her husband of the spouse-sponsored podcast. The episode begins with the relaxed, question-led tone Elizabeth uses with guests, then moves into something more personal. Connie talks about how easy it is for people to get defined by what they do, what they enjoy, and how they perform. Emotions change, hobbies change, and jobs and other roles matter too, but none of those things should become identity. That turns the conversation toward the Lord and away from the pressure to build a self out of activity. Elizabeth and Connie stay with that idea long enough for it to settle in. Connie describes a moment when she felt the Holy Spirit talking to her while she was on a run. She says it happened just a couple of weeks before the recording, which makes the story feel immediate and unscripted. From there, she rewinds and explains how she found Elizabeth in the first place. She had been looking for a coach who could help her become more consistent with running. At first, she tried to figure it out on her own. That sent her into research loops, where she kept looking for the best plans and the best way to do everything. She says she could not actually apply all of that knowledge to herself, and the research itself started to feel like a trap. Over time, the amount of mental energy she was spending on training ideas became too much. Connie calls that obsession what it was and says it had become an idol in her mind. That is where the episode gets especially honest. She realized she was thinking about training plans so much that it was crowding out better things. She wanted to let something go. She wanted help, but she also wanted help from someone who shared her faith. That desire shaped her search for a Christian coach. She knew plenty of coaches could write a plan and handle the training details. What she wanted was more than that: someone who could hold running and faith in the same space. Elizabeth gives her room to say that plainly. The identity thread deepens when Connie says her emotions do not define her and her hobbies do not define her. She points to the fruit of the Spirit as a mark of belonging, while still saying identity should come from the Lord. That distinction matters in the episode. It is not anti-running. It is a reminder to keep God at the center of it. Elizabeth responds with warmth and keeps the conversation steady. The exchange feels like two people working through something real rather than delivering a polished message. Connie's story stays personal, but the lesson reaches anyone who has started to let a sport, a role, or a routine carry too much weight. The prayer at the end gathers the episode's themes into one simple request for freedom, clarity, and a return to God as the source of identity.

As heard by us

A trail running conversation about identity, coaching, and keeping God at the center.

Connie and Coach Elizabeth keep circling a plain question: does she call herself a runner? The conversation moves from trail running to ultra crewing to the way hobbies, jobs, and training can start to look like identity.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If running has started to feel like it is taking up too much space, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on