RTP's Fourth Branch Podcast

Tech Roundup Episode 27 - AI on the Senate Floor: Is it Time for a Moratorium?

·41 min·4 clips
The House just approved a 10-year moratorium on state AI regulation—what does this mean for innovation and control?
The program opens by noting that the speakers' views are their own. Libby Dickinson, Assistant Director with the Regulatory Transparency Project, introduces a panel of technology and legal experts gathered to discuss AI preemption. Dr. Scott Babwa-Brennan is identified as Director of the Center for Technology Policy at NYU. Kevin Frazier is identified as AI Innovation and Law Fellow at the UT Austin School of Law. Adam Thier is identified as Senior Fellow of Technology and Innovation at R Street Institute. Frazier first points to Thier's testimony before the House Energy and Commerce Subcommittee on Commerce, Manufacturing and Trade a few days earlier. The conversation is set on the Friday before Memorial Day weekend, and Frazier briefly nods to burgers, camping, and tents before the policy work begins. One thread asks whether a moratorium on regulating foundation models could make sense. The panel then turns to a bill provision with a ten-year duration and what it would mean to give it that much runway. That time span matters because the federal government is described as slow to act. The speakers examine language covering artificial intelligence models, artificial intelligence systems, and automated decision systems, with definitions broad enough to include systems using AI in whole or in part. Social media platforms become one example of what that breadth might capture, while state procurement rules raise a separate concern about governmental choices. Those examples give the abstract preemption debate a sharper institutional feel. The discussion separates the broad relationship between innovation and regulation from the more exact task of stress-testing the provision's wording. It asks who should be at the table when those interests are balanced. It also asks whether the language would leave the country in a workable position for future regulation. Adam Thier adds historical perspective by referring to The Delicate Balance, Federalism, Interstate Commerce, and Technological Freedom, a book he says he wrote 28 years ago for the Heritage Foundation. The reference frames the current fight as part of a longer debate over federalism and technological freedom. The exchange becomes a careful debate over the scope, duration, and practical effects of AI preemption. Libby Dickinson closes by thanking the speakers and pointing listeners to the Regulatory Transparency Project's programming and website.

As heard by us

A measured discussion of how a 10-year AI preemption rule could reshape state regulatory choices.

AI preemption comes through as a fight over governmental reach. A 10-year limit on state AI regulation could stretch well beyond foundation models, depending on how the bill defines AI models, AI systems, and automated decision systems.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to know whether a ten-year AI moratorium would buy regulatory clarity or leave states with too little room to act.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on