Rotoworld Baseball Show – Fantasy Baseball · D.J. Short, NBC Sports, Rotoworld Baseball

Struggling Hitters: Paul Goldschmidt, Corbin Carroll, and others + Key Injuries

May 15, 2024·1 hr 10 min·5 clips
Paul Goldschmidt's shocking .205 average and 32% strikeout rate spark debate: is the former MVP now a fantasy liability?
The episode opens with news. Eric Smulski and Scott Pianowski begin with the injured-list board, including Reese Hoskins to the IL with a hamstring injury and a Brewers timeline of two to four weeks, then use that as a springboard into replacement thinking. Then comes the waiver talk. They look at Tampa Bay’s second-base mess, mention Richie Palacios as a possible piece in the mix, and explain why Brandon Lowe no longer brings much confidence. Rehab watch follows. Chris Bryant and Nolan Jones are both set to begin rehab assignments, and the hosts split them into different fantasy bets by cost, trust, and how much long-term faith is left. Jones gets the kinder read. The conversation suggests he is the better speculative pickup if the price is low enough, while Bryant is treated as a player whose past accomplishments no longer buy much present-day optimism. Goldschmidt is next. The hosts call him a forced hold for now, arguing that a dead market makes it smarter to wait for a rebound stretch before trying to trade him or deciding that the bounce is real. They keep the same logic. Slumping veterans are handled as timing problems and market problems, with the advice changing depending on whether a manager needs production now or can wait for the first hot week. Bo Bichette enters late. The hosts think an approach change could help him, and the discussion shifts toward what kind of adjustment might unlock better results without overreacting to one bad stretch. The show stays brisk. Rather than lingering on any one name, it keeps moving back to role, health, and whether a player’s usage gives fantasy managers enough reason to hold, bid, or move on. The StatCast segment is brief. At the end, they quickly examine the new metrics and ask whether fantasy players should care, treating the topic as a useful but limited layer of context. The tone is practical. The whole episode is built to turn familiar names and daily news into immediate decisions for active fantasy baseball managers.

As heard by us

A practical fantasy baseball check-in on slumps and roster calls.

Roto-World Baseball Show stays on useful fantasy ground. Eric Smulski and Scott Pianowski open with news and notes, then work through hitters who have become awkward decisions for managers: cut, hold, or try to trade.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You need a clean read on Goldschmidt and the latest IL churn.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on