Rotoworld Baseball Show – Fantasy Baseball · D.J. Short, NBC Sports, Rotoworld Baseball

Spencer Strider headlines pitcher injuries + Brendan Donovan and more Waiver Wire adds

April 8, 2024·1 hr 9 min·5 clips
Spencer Strider and Shane Bieber's injuries have left fantasy players reeling—what does this mean for the season?
The episode starts with bad news. Eric and Scott frame the weekend as another reminder that pitching injuries can flip a fantasy season overnight, and they immediately connect that reality to the loss of Spencer Strider and the follow-up concern around Shane Bieber. They do not linger on the drama. Instead, they treat the injuries as a roster problem, asking which stars still deserve patience and which situations force managers to rethink draft boards and weekly lineup choices. Scott compares pitching injuries to the way running back injuries shape fantasy football. That comparison sets the tone for the rest of the conversation, which is less about emotion and more about how fast value can vanish when an arm goes down. The hosts spend time on the changing class of ace pitchers. They talk about how names such as Kershaw, Scherzer, Verlander, deGrom, and Garrett Cole show a position in transition, with Strider described as a new SP1 before the injury news pulled him off the board. Then they widen the lens. The discussion moves into whether certain injured pitchers are healthy enough to trust, and whether the market is leaving value on the table because teams are not always fully clear about arm trouble. Braxton Garrett gets a careful look. The hosts note that the Marlins' injury reporting can be hard to read, but they still see enough strikeout ability and control-driven volume to justify stashing him in deeper leagues. Walker Buehler comes next. His rehab progress is treated as meaningful, especially after a dominant second rehab start and a note that one more minor league outing may be all that stands between him and a return, which suggests the Dodgers are confident enough to bring him back. Gray gets a slight edge over Buehler. Even so, both pitchers are described as roster-worthy in most leagues, which keeps the focus on when to invest rather than whether the talent is good. Aaron Ashby and Nick Lodolo round out the stash-and-watch group. Scott and Eric separate the two by readiness, with Ashby's spring performance keeping him more in watch mode and Lodolo looking like the kind of arm who could produce a strikeout spike once he settles. The conversation keeps circling back to format. It ends with a practical promise to return on Wednesday, when the hosts expect hitting stats to be a little steadier and want to sort hot starters by whether the batted-ball and plate-discipline changes are real.

As heard by us

A sharp injury-and-waiver scan that turns bad pitching news into usable fantasy decisions.

Eric Samulski and Scott Pianowski keep the focus on fantasy fallout from a rough weekend for pitching injuries, with Spencer Strider and Shane Bieber setting the tone before the conversation broadens into roster and IL calls.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If your rotation just took a hit, this is the waiver and stash briefing you need.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on