Rotoworld Baseball Show – Fantasy Baseball · D.J. Short, NBC Sports, Rotoworld Baseball

Paul Skenes Shines, Edwin Diaz Demoted + Luis Matos, Alek Manoah among Waiver Wire Targets

May 20, 2024·1 hr 8 min·5 clips
Paul Skenes' second MLB start was so unhittable, it reminded one host of Kerry Wood's legendary game.
This one is a waiver-wire checkpoint. Eric Samulski and Scott Pianowski open with the injuries and roster questions fantasy managers are already facing, then use them as the backdrop for a broader week-ahead conversation about who is climbing, who is slipping, and who deserves roster attention. The tone stays practical throughout. They keep coming back to the same decision tree: buy, hold, stash, cut, or watch, because that is how a real fantasy week gets managed when injuries and playing-time shifts hit all at once. Miguel Vargas becomes the case study. His Triple-A production, including a .295 average, eight home runs, eight stolen bases, a 19% walk rate, and a 16.5% strikeout rate in 39 games, gives them enough to ask whether the bat is finally catching up to the tools, even if the major-league picture is still messy. Context matters. They note that Vargas is only 24, that he can play multiple positions, and that the Dodgers have enough lineup pressure to make even interesting players feel temporary, especially when batting near the bottom. The buyback question is real. In deeper leagues, they lean toward getting in now rather than waiting for a cleaner moment, while in most redraft settings they frame him more as a watch-list player unless something opens up. The skepticism never really goes away. Even when the numbers point to category juice and solid plate discipline, they keep stressing that strong minor-league indicators do not guarantee immediate fantasy usefulness, and that not every hot stretch survives contact with a crowded major-league roster. That is the show's rhythm. They move quickly, but they do not rush past the details; every quick agreement gets followed by a caveat about league depth, sample size, usage, or whether the player is actually likely to stay on the field. There is a little banter too. The hosts joke about favorites, family leagues, and the way fantasy managers start rooting for stability once the standings harden in May, which keeps the conversation human without drifting into fluff. The advice stays grounded. If a player has one appealing skill but no stable path to at-bats or innings, they treat that as a warning sign, not a reason to get swept up in the name value. It sounds like active management from start to finish. The episode is built for listeners who want a current, skeptical read on the player pool and a clear sense of how to turn news into an actual roster move.

As heard by us

A waiver-wire check that values role, context, and patience over hype.

Fantasy baseball in mid-May is a useful time to separate real movement from short-term noise, and this episode stays focused on that job. Eric Samulski and Scott Pianowski work through injury updates and roster questions with a practical fantasy frame, asking what a player means…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When your roster needs a Monday waiver read and a cheap upside name to track.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on