Rotoworld Baseball Show – Fantasy Baseball · D.J. Short, NBC Sports, Rotoworld Baseball

Mike Trout Injured + Friends & Family Draft Reaction, Surprises

May 1, 2024·1 hr 10 min·5 clips
Scott Pianowski compares Mike Trout's career arc to Ken Griffey Jr. and Mickey Mantle, questioning how history will remember him.
Eric Smolsky opens the show with Scott Pianowski and a returning DJ Short. A barking-dog moment sets the tone before they get going. They move through news and notes quickly. Then the show shifts into the Yahoo Friends and Family Draft, which took place a month into the season. That timing matters because the room is not trying to relive preseason rankings. It is trying to see what the first month has really changed. The question is simple: if they knew now what they knew then, where would pitchers go, and which hitters would fast rise up? That makes the draft feel less like a recap and more like a reset. The conversation keeps coming back to how much weight one month deserves. Scott makes the case that some early moves are real and some are just noise. DJ brings the practical fantasy lens that keeps the discussion tied to roster decisions. L.A. De La Cruz becomes the biggest case study. They talk through where he went in the draft and whether that price was fair. They also dig into his improved plate discipline. At the same time, they flag his split issues, especially against left-handed pitching. The group points to his rough numbers there and his much stronger production against righties. They also note the huge homer-to-fly-ball rate, which looks due for regression. That turns the talk into a broader question about volatility, not just one player. The room keeps separating first-round skill from first-round pricing. Later, the conversation widens to other names and pitching notes. Jackson Holliday comes up near the close, along with the blunt view that he would not be rostered right now. Eric also points listeners to his NBC Sports column. DJ mentions an upcoming power-rankings piece. The back end of the show touches on pitch-mix work for Kevin Gossman, Dylan Cease, and Ben Lively. The episode closes with social plugs and a promise to return Monday with a weekend recap.

As heard by us

A draft-room reset that turns early-season noise into fantasy baseball decisions.

The show uses a month-old Yahoo Friends and Family draft to test early fantasy baseball instincts. Eric Smolsky, Scott Pianowski, and DJ Short keep circling the same practical questions: what changed, what held, and what now looks volatile.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A month into the season, Eric Smolsky, Scott Pianowski, and DJ Short help you recalibrate the board.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on