Rosie the Reviewer: a WW2 movies and shows podcast · Rosie the Reviewer

Ep 92 – Hart’s War – A Courtroom drama set Inside a POW Camp

·51 min·3 clips

The camp's worst racist is found dead, and the Black pilot becomes the obvious suspect.

Rosie the Reviewer opens with a discussion of Parts War, a 2002 film directed by Gregory Hoblet and written by Billy Ray and Terry George. The movie is adapted from John Katzenbach's 1999 novel of the same name. Sam and Margie describe it as a mostly fictional story about a racially motivated court-martial inside a POW camp during World War II. They both respond well to the cast, especially Colin Farrell, Bruce Willis, and Terrence Howard. The Tuskegee Airmen element also works for them as part of what makes the film appealing. Margie says she was invested from start to finish. Sam agrees that the movie is enjoyable, even if it is not a standard war movie. They like that it mixes war film with legal drama. The conversation keeps circling back to how unusual that blend feels. Because Margie read the book first, she notices the adaptation choices more sharply. The show spends time on what the movie keeps and what it leaves out. One major point of comparison is the setup around the murder at the center of the story. In the book, Hart is a Yale law student before the war and is assigned to defend Scott at the court-martial. The hosts note that this background helps explain the courtroom setup in the story. They also talk through the book's version of the murder taking place in the camp bathroom. In that version, the lack of blood at the scene makes it clear that the killing happened elsewhere. That detail helps Hart realize the body was moved to hide the real crime scene. The book also makes the frame-up feel more deliberate because Scott's jacket and flight boots are put on him. The hosts think the movie's changes soften that logic. They keep returning to why those changes were made at all. Their frustration comes from how much the alteration changes the story's meaning. The episode ends on a light note, with a mention of The Perfect Horse as a possible future pick. The overall effect is warm, chatty, and grounded in both movie reaction and book comparison.

As heard by us

A warm World War II courtroom discussion that sharpens where the book and film diverge.

Hart's War is a 2002 World War II courtroom drama with an unusual setup, and Sam and Margie keep it easy to track. They seem genuinely taken with the cast, and the conversation stays centered on what the film does well while also weighing where the novel may have the cleaner…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a WWII movie talk that digs into the adaptation choices?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Rosie the Reviewer: a WW2 movies and shows podcast